Street

Hanging Out with Christopher Columbus, the Oversized Diva

by Jillian Steinhauer on September 20, 2012

Tatzu Nishi’s “Discovering Columbus” in Columbus Circle

Tatzu Nishi’s “Discovering Columbus” in Columbus Circle (click to enlarge) (all photos by the author for Hyperallergic)

From down on the ground, if you didn’t know what it was, it might be hard to figure it out. Given the massive amounts of scaffolding, the big structure currently occupying the middle of Columbus Circle looks basically like a construction project with nifty yellow signs attached. It’s actually the Public Art Fund’s latest project, “Discovering Columbus,” by Japanese artist Tatzu Nishi.

For the project, Nishi has topped 70 feet of scaffolding with an artificial living room, which is furnished with such typically bland American trappings as taupe chairs and a rug, a plum couch, and a flat screen TV. At the center of the living room is a black coffee table, and at the center of that, seeming to rest on the table, is a giant, 13-foot marble statue of Christopher Columbus.

Columbus commands the living room.

Columbus in the center of the living room

But let’s start at the beginning. First, you must receive a timed entry ticket. Then, you must sign a waiver. After that, you climb six flights of stairs, during which time you may peek through the thicket of scaffolding to glimpse the column that forms most of the very tall (more than 75 feet high) Columbus monument, which is topped by the statue of the explorer in the room upstairs. The entire monument was designed by Italian sculptor Gaetano Russo and unveiled in 1892.

Starting on the ground, looking up

A glimpse of the monument’s base column through the scaffolding

When you at last arrive at the top, you are greeted by a small hallway/foyer, which is wonderfully clever on Nishi’s part because it creates a sense of scale. If there aren’t any people in sight here, you could easily picture them milling about, maybe drinking cocktails before or after a dinner party in an imaginary adjacent dining room.

The hallway/foyer

But then you proceed ahead a few steps, turn to your right, and there he is — Columbus, larger than life and commanding an utterly plain, lifelike room. It’s hard not laugh; I did. And not out of derision, but because it’s really just funny. His grandiosity makes the room seem silly. Columbus has never been either so accessible or so out of place.

Columbus's feet

Columbus’s feet juxtaposed with the “New York Times” and the TV

And yet, there’s a way in which Columbus fits his surroundings perfectly. The living room, as Nishi has decorated and arranged it, is for the most part a carefully cultivated model of tasteful tastelessness. Save for the quirky wallpaper, it conforms to our expectations of middlebrow luxury, trying so hard to be classy that it ends up uninteresting. One of the photographers who visited at the same time as me remarked that it felt like a setting in a James Bond movie, and I think he was onto something: the room is a parody of itself.

In much the same vein, what we discover when we have a chance to view Russo’s sculpture up close is that his Columbus is sort of a parody, too. He’s affected, trying hard, with his showy pose, to look like a fearless explorer. I couldn’t help but think he looked like an oversized diva.

Christopher Columbus strikes a pose.

Christopher Columbus strikes a pose.

Of course the beauty of the project is that none of these thoughts and postulations would be possible without the room itself: it creates the conditions that render its own presence sort of ridiculous. So after all that thinking, it’s probably best to spend the next twenty minutes of your allotted time simply sitting in a plush chair and hanging out with Christopher Columbus. You could also look out the windows and over the outside railing to admire the wonderful views that Nishi has created for us.

Looking south down Eighth Avenue

Looking south down Eighth Avenue from atop “Discovering Columbus”

A view of Columbus Circle from six stories up

Not for those with vertigo: a view of Columbus Circle from six stories up.

After I had descended, I crossed to the other side of Columbus Circle and turned back for one last look. Rather than only seeing the scaffolding now, I noticed the neat white box of the living room perched on top. If there’s one critique to be made of “Discovering Columbus,” it’s probably that the domestic setting softens Columbus too much, to the point where his troubling legacy is either ignored or forgotten. Nishi might have included some alternative historical accounts among the reading material on offer upstairs (although I’m not sure if visitors are allowed to remove books from the bookshelf). Otherwise, though, the artist and the Public Art Fund have done delightfully just what these sorts of projects should: found a way to bring the public closer to public art.

A view of "Discovering Columbus" in Columbus Circle

A view from across the street

Tatzu Nishi: Discovering Columbus is on view at Columbus Circle (West 59th Street and Eight Avenue) through November 18. Tickets are required but free. More information is available here.

  • Subscribe to the Hyperallergic newsletter!

Hyperallergic welcomes comments and a lively discussion, but comments are moderated after being posted. For more details please read our comment policy.
  • http://www.facebook.com/joanna.black JoAnna Black

    I work up the street from here and love the idea of this project but hate that we have a monument to Columbus.

    • http://twitter.com/jilnotjill Jillian Steinhauer

      That seems totally fair, but you should go see it! I think it’ll make you think.

    • http://benjaminvalentine.com/ Ben Valentine

      It is problematic to have a monument to Columbus, but I like this better than demolishing the monument. I think this is a good start. Would you prefer it destroyed?

      • http://hragv.com Hrag Vartanian

        I think someone should come up with a process to deaccession public art. I would vote to have Fred Wilson add to the work.

        • http://benjaminvalentine.com/ Ben Valentine

          Agreed. And I don’t have a proposal for how to do that on hand – but it is something we really need to resolve.

  • http://www.facebook.com/brianmoz Brian Fernandes-Halloran

    I cannot wait to see this. So amazing!! Im guessing that having to physically walk up the steps ads to the impact.

    • http://twitter.com/jilnotjill Jillian Steinhauer

      You know, surprisingly, it didn’t really affect me. The PAF made so much fuss about the stairs, I expected to be all tired and out of breath, but really it was fine. And since you’re fairly enveloped in scaffolding along the way, you don’t get much of a view until you’re finally at the top.

      • http://www.facebook.com/brianmoz Brian Fernandes-Halloran

        I just like the idea you gotta do some work to reach him. Being primed for the viewing, with a little sweat and raised heartbeat is nice. It makes mountaintop views more pretty :)

        • http://twitter.com/jilnotjill Jillian Steinhauer

          Definitely. And it makes the penthouse feel all the sweeter.

Previous post:

Next post: