Articles

Tracing the Legacies of Postwar UK’s Lost and Damaged Public Artworks

City Sculpture ProjectNicholas Monro, King Kong, for the City Sculpture Project, 1972, the Bull Ring Birmingham. Eight cities were loaned sculptures by emerging artists with the option to buy them. Only one of the 16 pieces commissioned was kept in situ. Some were even deliberately destroyed highlighting the negative attitude to ‘modern’ art. Copyright Arnolfini ArchiveExhibition details for Out There
Nicholas Monro, “King Kong” (1972) © Arnolfini Archive (all images courtesy Historic England)

Last December, after cultural preservationists in England realized that many of the nation’s postwar public sculpture have disappeared from the landscape over a number of decades, they issued a public call to attempt to trace or even recover them. Historic England (HE) — a public body charged with protecting the country’s historic environment — had discovered that theft, vandalism, suspicious sales, or other mysterious incidents have removed many commissioned works from their original sites. Along with developing a database of lost and destroyed public art, it also last month created new listings of 40 postwar sculptures that mark them as historic and gives them extra protection. It includes the first Antony Gormley to be listed (a figure cupping its ear to listen to its surroundings), an early two-piece bronze by Henry Moore, Edward Paolozzi’s towering “Ventilation Shaft Cover” (1982), and three works by Barbara Hepworth. The vulnerability of public works became increasingly clear during HE’s research, prompting the creation of Out There: Our Post-War Public Art, an exhibition at Somerset House, to remember lost works between 1945 and 1985 and revisit their histories while building awareness of the threats to public art.

William Mitchell, "The Spirit of Brighton" (1968) in Brighton, East Sussex, destroyed in 1992 (© QueenSpark Books)
William Mitchell, “The Spirit of Brighton” (1968) in Brighton, East Sussex, destroyed in 1992 (© QueenSpark Books) (click to enlarge)

Created for the outdoors such as spaces in parks and areas by housing projects, schools, and hospitals, these sculptures emerged as part of a huge postwar construction boom, as curator Sarah Gaventa told Hyperallergic.

“They were part of an ambitious program to bring art to the people, instigated by the post-war labor government and the newly formed Arts Council and local authorities who were encouraged — by the Ministry of Education, for example — to commission art to improve the local environment for the public,” Gaventa said. “The new subject matter was more relevant to the public and their lives. It was also a form of social engineering to encourage certain behaviors … representing civil harmony and peace.”

Unfortunately, many of these works instead became targets of social disobedience, treated as canvases for graffiti or seen as pieces of scrap metal freely available for selling. Many of the sculptures the exhibition remembers — through photographs, drawings, documents, and maquettes — are confirmed as destroyed. At times it was public dissatisfaction that led to sorry fates: Barry Flanagan’s “The Cambridge Piece” (1972), for instance, was not well received and experienced multiple wounds from vandals until it was beyond repair. One local vicar had apparently also written to the press and asked that those in charge “blow up revolting art!” Other sculptures simply stood in the way of development projects, such as William Mitchell’s “The Spirit of Brighton” (1968), whose own custodians — Standard Life Investments — demolished the sand-blasted piece without consulting anyone to make way for a shopping center.

Antony Gormley, "Untitled [Listening]" (1983-84) at Maygrove Peace Park, London (© Historic England)
Antony Gormley, “Untitled [Listening]” (1983-84) at Maygrove Peace Park, London (© Historic England)
Private Public ArtInstallation of Barbara Hepworth’s Winged Figure, 1961-2, Holles Street, London, with the artist looking on. The private sector was also pivotal in the creation of important works of art. Hepworth’s Winged Figure which she created for the John Lewis Partnership is a key example of sculpture commissioned for commercial premises. Copyright John Lewis Partnership Archives
Barbara Hepworth with her Winged Figure (1961-62) on Holles Street, London, recently listed as Grade II* (© John Lewis Partnership Archives)

The heavy weights of many of these sculptures also did not fail to deter thieves from making off with them. A large reclining figure by Henry Moore disappeared in 2005 while being prepared for an exhibition in Japan, with police believing the £3 million (~$4.1 million USD) work was melted down for scrap in exchange for £1,500 (~ 2000 USD); one of Lynn Chadwick’s figures in “The Watchers” (1960) was separated from the sculptural trio in 2006, sawed off at its feet. Police estimate that at least eight people had to be involved to cart away the over six-foot-tall piece.

Pieces with such murky pasts are marked as “lost” or “disappeared,” and they appear on a wall in the exhibition like missing people or pets, displayed in the hope that someone may have tips concerning their whereabouts. Although intended to be site-specific, these sculptures have ended up traveling, making tracing them an arduous process. Nicholas Monro’s giant “King Kong” gorilla, for instance, created for the 1972 City Sculpture Project, moved multiple times, was subject to numerous cases of vandalism, and even experienced makeovers — from a pink paint-job to a Santa Claus disguise. Furthermore, no database ever existed of all the work from this period, as Gaventa said, and their histories were never recorded. Although Historic England at times has tracked some of these sculptures to private homes, auctions, storage rooms, or temporary sites for repair, sometimes the trail of evidence ends and only questions remain.

Barry Flanagan, "The Cambridge Piece" (1972), destroyed from vandalism (© Arnolfini)
Barry Flanagan, “The Cambridge Piece” (1972), destroyed from vandalism (© Arnolfini)
Lynn Chadwick, "The Watchers" (1960) at Roehampton University, South West London, stolen in 2006 (© Historic England)
Lynn Chadwick, “The Watchers” (1960) at Roehampton University, South West London, stolen in 2006 (© Historic England)

Thanks to a lot of detective-like work spearheaded by Gaventa and members of HE, however, some of these previously missing works have turned up. Aside from spending a lot of time in archives digging through uncatalogued boxes to try and learn about their stories, the team was also in contact with private collectors, some of the artists, and the artists’ families. Because of these endeavors, they have found some casts of lost works and even recovered some original sculptures that are on display in Out There. One successful find is a massive fiberglass relief by Paul Mount, which was marked for removal from a supermarket it decorated but later saved from destruction. Similarly, the fate of another relief by Trevor Tennant, which once adorned the entrance hall of a hospital, was threatened by the institution’s closure until a doctor recovered it. As such stories, along with Gaventa and HE’s own efforts exemplify, the efforts and knowledge of individuals are instrumental to bring back work originally intended to be accessible to all. Out There hopes to make their value as pieces of artistic heritage clear and appreciate and to prevent any future need to embark on complicated searches.

“The public needs to rally around local work to protect it, suggest pieces for listing to HE,” Gaventa said. “If a piece is no longer able to stay in its original home  – a new location should be found for it, rather than it being scrapped or destroyed during demolition of a building, which often happens simply because it is the easiest option.

“This heritage is irreplaceable,” she said. “It reminds us of a more ambitious age of equality and hope — and it needs our protection.”

Chadwick and Mount
Relief by Paul Mount and Lynn Chadwick’s “Trigon” (1961) (© Historic England)
Installation of New Horizons by Trevor Tennant © Historic England
Installation of Trevor Tennant’s “New Horizons” at the Somerset House (© Historic England)
Arthur Fleischmann, Miranda, 1951. Image of the artist in the studio with the work and model. Reproduced with kind permission from the Arthur Fleischmann Archive.
Arthur Fleischmann in the studio with his sculpture “Miranda” (1951), which mysteriously disappeared in 2000, and his model (Reproduced with permission from the Arthur Fleischmann Archive)
Henry Moore, “Draped Seated Woman” (1957–58) at Yorkshire Sculpture Park (© Historic England)
Barbara Hepworth, Contrapuntal Forms, 1951, Glebelands housing area, Harlow
Barbara Hepworth carving “Contrapuntal Forms” in Harlow on October 25, 1950 (© Historic England)
contrapuntal sculpture.© Harlow Arts Trust
Barbara Hepworth, “Contrapuntal Forms” (1951) at Glebelands housing area, Harlow (© Harlow Arts Trust)
aa51_06174.tif
Heinz Henghes, “Orpheus” (1951) at the Festival of Britain, a maquette of which is on view in Out There (© Historic England Archive)
Public Sculpture 'London' by Eduardo Paolozzi,1982. Adjacent to Pimlico London Underground Station, London.
Eduardo Paolozzi, “Ventilation Shaft Cover,” (1982) at Pimlico, London, recently listed as Grade II (© Historic England)
Public sculpture 'Children Playingl' by Peter Laszio Peri. Artwork dated 1948 Darley House, Tyers Street, Vauxhall Gardens Estate, Lambeth, London Relief sculpture on staircase tower
Peter Laszlo Peri, “Following the Leader (Memorial to the Children Killed in the Blitz)” (1949) at Vauxhall, London, recently listed as Grade II (© Historic England)
The Story of Wool by William Mitchell, 1968. International Development Centre, Valley Drive, Ilkley, West Yorkshire. Listed Grade II This is a stylised flock of sheep complete with careful detailing of their curled horns, cloven hooves and thick fleeces. It was made from glass reinforced plastic, a material the artist William Mitchell pioneered as a cheaper, lighter alternative to bronze. This was commissioned for the new Technical Centre of the International Wool Secretariat, an organisation established to promote the use and trade of wool in response to the increased use of synthetic fibres in the 50s and 60s. The centre was built in 1968 in Ilkley, as West Yorkshire was the main centre of the British woollen textile industry. © Historic England
William Mitchell, “The Story of Wool” (1968) at the International Development Centre, Valley Drive, Ilkley, West Yorkshire, recently listed as Grade II (© Historic England)
'Out There- Saving Public Art' expo at Somerset House, Arthur Fleischmann, sculptor. Anderton Shearer Mining Memorial, 1963-5, Bronze, Originally sited as a fountain at The National Coal Board, Anderton House, Lowton, Lancashire. Relocated to Rivington Colliery roundabout, St. Helen’s, Merseyside.
Arthur Fleischmann, “The Miner” at St Helens (1964) (© Historic England)
Post War Public Art. Boar (1970) by Elisabeth Frink, The Water Gardens, Harlow, Essex. Detail view from the south east.
Elisabeth Frink, “Boar” (1970) at Water Gardens, Harlow town centre in 2015, recently listed as Grade II (© Historic England)
Unveiling day for Siegfried Charoux’s The Neighbours, Highbury Quadrant Estate, 1959, London. In 1956 the London County Council set up the Patronage of the Arts Scheme, where money was set aside each year to purchase such works of art.
Unveiling day for Siegfried Charoux’s “The Neighbours” (1959) at Highbury Quadrant Estate, London (© Islington Museum)
Post War Public Art. Seven reliefs/mosaics (1963) by William Mitchell, The Water Gardens, Harlow, Essex. Detail view from the south of relief/mosaic No.4 (ordered from west to east)
William Mitchell, detail of seven reliefs/mosaics (1963) at The Water Gardens, Harlow, Essex (© Historic England.The Water Gardens)
Post War Public Art. Seven reliefs/mosaics (1963) by William Mitchell, The Water Gardens, Harlow, Essex. Detail view from the south east of relief/mosaic No.2 (ordered from west to east)
William Mitchell, detail of seven reliefs/mosaics (1963) at The Water Gardens, Harlow, Essex (© Historic England.The Water Gardens)
One of Mark Wallinger's Labyrinth prints will be on display in Out There. Labyrinth, Mark Wallinger, Network wide London Underground, Commissioned by Art on the Underground, 2013. Photo: Thierry Bal
Mark Wallinger, print from ‘Labyrinth’ project (2013), an example of which is on view in Out There (photo by Thierry Bal)
Wrapper, Jacqueline Poncelet, Edgware Road station, Commissioned by Art on the Underground, 2012. Photo: Thierry Bal
Jacqueline Poncelet, “Wrapper” (2012) at Edgware Road station, designs for which are on view in Out There (photo by Thierry Bal)
donkey sculpture © Harlow Arts Trust
Willi Soukop, “Donkey” (1955) at Pitmans Field (off Monkswick Road), Mark Hall South, Harlow, newly listed as Grade II (© Harlow Museum)
Post War Public Sculpture Greater London.
Geoffrey Clarke, “Spirit of Electricity” (1958-61) on the side of Thorn House, St Martin’s Lane, London, newly listed as Grade II (© Historic England)
City Sculpture ProjectNicholas Monro, King Kong, for the City Sculpture Project, 1972, the Bull Ring Birmingham. Eight cities were loaned sculptures by emerging artists with the option to buy them. Only one of the 16 pieces commissioned was kept in situ. Some were even deliberately destroyed highlighting the negative attitude to ‘modern’ art. Copyright Arnolfini ArchiveExhibition details for Out There
Nicholas Monro, “King Kong” (1972) © Arnolfini Archive
a rowing boat on the boating lake at battersea park with legs sticking out of it, ripples on the water and the sculpture 'single form' by barbara hepworth in the distance battersea park single form sculpture greater london wandsworth battersea
Archive photo of Barbara Hepworth’s “Single Form (Memorial)” (1961-62) at Battersea Park, London, newly listed as Grade II* (© Historic England Archive)
William Pye sculptue "Zemran", 1972. Located on the South Bank, Lambeth, Greater London. View from north west.
William Pye, “Zemran” (1972) on the South Bank, Lambeth, Greater London, newly listed as Grade II (© Historic England)

Out There: Our Post-War Public Art continues at Somerset House (Strand, London WC2R 1LA, United Kingdom) through April 10.

comments (0)