A sculpture of a Hindu deity looted from a Kathmandu Valley temple in the 1980s and exhibited at the Dallas Museum of Art (DMA) has been repatriated to Nepal. The sacred Stele of Lakshmi-Narayana was purchased at an auction in 1990 and loaned to the DMA, where it had been on display for nearly 30 years when Erin L. Thompson, an art crime professor at John Jay College, tweeted about its questionable provenance, expounding on it in a January 2020 article for Hyperallergic.
The DMA removed the stele from view on December 16, 2019, a month after Thompson’s tweet, and said it would investigate the claims. In a joint effort by the museum and the FBI, the statue was transported from Dallas to Washington, DC, and returned to Nepali custody on March 5 this year.
Nepal banned the export of historic statues of deities through its Ancient Monuments Preservation Act of 1956. However, authorities estimate that tens of thousands of Nepalese antiquities have been plundered and sold in a multibillion-dollar global black market since the country opened its borders to tourists. Many of those artifacts are thought to be housed in private collections and public institutions across the United States.
Against this backdrop, the story of the Stele of Lakshmi-Narayana has a comparatively happier ending.
“The Dallas Museum of Art is committed to responsible stewardship of the objects in our care and rigorous provenance standards. As soon as we became aware of additional information on the stele, we began working with the lender and with the Embassy of Nepal to determine an ethical and appropriate course of action,” said DMA director Agustín Arteaga in a statement.
However, some are questioning why the repatriation didn’t happen sooner — especially given the sculpture’s well-documented status as stolen.
The distinctive figure of Hindu deities Vishnu and his consort Lakshmi in composite form is reproduced and described in Krishna Deva’s Images of Nepal (1984) and Lain Singh Bangdel’s Stolen Images of Nepal (1989), two of the most cited sources for researching stolen deity statues, Thompson tells Hyperallergic. One of those titles, the Bangdel book, is actually housed in the DMA library, she adds.
“The museum claimed they acted when ‘new information became available,’ and numerous media reports have reprinted these claims,” Thompson said. “But the information was far from new. Information about the theft of this stele was published, in English, in Bangdel’s 1989 book — which sits on the shelves of the museum’s own library. The information was available decades before the museum acted on it.”
“The museum acted not when information about the theft was available, but when information about their failure to act on this information became public,” she continued.
A museum spokesperson told Hyperallergic that the book in question was acquired in 2020 in connection with research it was conducting into the stele. “The DMA conducts research on objects in our care on an ongoing basis, and we are constantly confirming new information about works of art, both at the DMA and from within the broader community of museums and scholars,” the representative continued. “When we identify concerns about an object, we act on that information responsibly and continue to do so.”
The Lakshmi-Narayana sculpture was sold in a Sotheby’s auction of Indian, Himalayan and Southeast Asian Art in March 1990 and landed in the hands of Dallas art collector David T. Owsley, a longtime patron of the DMA and namesake of the museum’s Owsley Galleries of South Asian Art, where the stele was exhibited. The publication of Bangdel’s book predates Sotheby’s sale by a year. (A spokesperson for the auction house has not yet responded to Hyperallergic’s request for comment.)
In her article for Hyperallergic, Thompson described investigations into the Kathmandu icon by artist Joy Lynn Davis and writer and activist Kanak Mani Dixit. Davis, who was working on a series of photorealistic paintings about stolen Nepalese deities, had come across a blurry image of the sculpture at the DMA on a blog and immediately recognized the statue. She had learned about it during an artist’s residency from Dixit, who knew the work had been sold but not where it had ended up.
When Thompson raised concerns about its provenance to the DMA in 2019, the museum asked for an official police report. But Nepal has never permitted the export of its art, Thompson notes, comparing the museum’s request to “saying ‘we need to check security footage from the boat’ when one of the passengers washes up on shore before you officially declare they’ve drowned.” (A spokesperson for the DMA told the Art Newspaper that asking whether a work has been reported stolen is “by no means an uncommon question as part of due diligence.”)
“It’s not enough for museums to sit and wait for claims — they need to be just as proactive about scouring their own collections for stolen sacred artifacts as they have been to make sure they don’t hold Nazi-looted art,” Thompson told Hyperallergic.
To this day, a shrine in the Narayan Temple in Patko Tol from which the work was stolen has held a small replica of the sculpture so its community could continue to worship Vishnu, one of the principal Hindu deities. The original statue’s reinstatement represents for many worshippers the long-awaited return of a symbol of a living god.
Goya’s Coded Love Letter to the Duchess of Alba
Goya neatly clothes himself in his own world of fantasy: He will have her in the end. In life, where the climate is much chillier, it was, alas, to be otherwise.
Witches Take Over Westchester
Bowen’s multimedia art is an alchemical mix of the sensuous and arcane, and it is more than a little witchy.
The Public Theater Explores the Hurricane Katrina Diaspora in shadow/land
Written by Erika Dickerson-Despenza and directed by Candis C. Jones, this lyrical meditation on legacy, erotic fugitivity, and self-determination is on view in NYC.
14 Art Books and Catalogues We’re Reading This Month
Anthologies and catalogues on feminist art in Latin America, Native mound building, Armenian photography, and more are on our reading list.
Saudi Arabia Announces $1M “Freedom of Expression” Art Award
Kanye West, Roman Polanski, and Carl Andre are among the shortlisted artists.
The Rubin Museum Presents Death Is Not the End
Tibetan Buddhist and Christian works of art made across 12 centuries explore death, the afterlife, and the desire to continue to exist. On view in NYC.
British Museum Offers Greece “Exclusive NFT” of the Parthenon Marbles
“With the power of blockchain technology, there will be no question who the real owner is,” said a British Museum spokesperson.
MoMA to Co-Curate Exhibition With NYPD
Arrest Me, Daddy hopes to cast a more positive light on the work of law enforcement officers.
When I Am Empty Please Dispose of Me Properly
Ayanna Dozier, Ilana Harris-Babou, Meena Hasan, Lucia Hierro, Catherine Opie, Chuck Ramirez, and Pacifico Silano explore the myths of the American Dream at Brooklyn’s BRIC House.
Repatriation-Inspired Fragrance Line Hopes to Heal Collector Wounds
The exotic scents of the Rapatriement line offer solace and joy to dismayed collectors who were forced to return looted artifacts.
Mediocre Painting Thought AI-Generated Revealed as Work of Real Artist
Visitors who spoke to Hyperallergic said they were “horrified” to learn that a human could come up with such a banal and poorly executed artwork.
Pratt’s 2023 Fine Arts MFA Thesis Exhibition Is On View in Brooklyn
The two-part exhibition features the work of 41 graduating artists across disciplines, including painting, sculpture, printmaking, and integrated practices.
Prince Harry to Star in New Van Gogh Biopic
The estranged prince said he took the role to raise awareness of mental health issues.
Newly Discovered Trove of Vermeer Works Reveals He Painted Mainly Dogs
A cache of 243 paintings found in an English castle, all depicting canine subjects, suggests Vermeer’s true aspiration was to become a dog portraitist.