Articles

What Happens When You Try to Photoshop Money

by Jillian Steinhauer on April 2, 2015

A “spocked” CAN$5 bill (image via Facebook)

A “spocked” CAN$5 bill (image via Facebook)

You may recall that last month, when actor Leonard Nimoy died, Canadians went into a frenzy “spocking” their $5 bills — aka drawing on the banknotes in order to turn former Canadian prime minister Wilfrid Laurier into Spock. When I was editing our story about the phenomenon, I discovered something curious: you can’t Photoshop money.

This may not come as news to everyone (someone on Reddit discovered it three years ago), but it was a surprise to us at Hyperallergic. Because it’s not just that you can’t Photoshop — as in edit in the Adobe program — money; you can’t even load an image of a CAN$5 banknote that’s already defaced to picture Spock and say “live long and prosper” into Photoshop. When I tried, here’s what happened:

PS-money-message3a

(screenshot by the author)

Clicking on that “Information” button takes you to the website of the Central Bank Counterfeit Deterrence Group, specifically a page titled “Banknotes & Counterfeit Deterrence,” which warns the visitor quite sternly:

Every country has legal restrictions on the reproduction of banknote images. The counterfeiting of currency is a crime, and while restrictions vary from country to country, in some countries, any reproduction of banknote images — even for artistic or advertising uses — is strictly forbidden. Even in countries that allow some limited use of banknote images, there are specific rules and requirements.

But of course, country-to-country rules and requirements don’t matter if you’re uniformly prohibited from importing images of money into Photoshop. Which appears to be the case, at least theoretically.

I wrote to Adobe to ask for an official statement or policy on Photoshopping images of money, but never heard back. I did find this conversation in a Photoshop community support board, in which an Adobe employee explains that the “CDS system” (counterfeit deterrence system, with a redundancy) has been a “feature … since Photoshop CS (8.0) released in 2003” and is a matter of “stay[ing] on the good side of law enforcement.” Accordingly, in an online forum (ah, good old forums) called The Photoshop Cafe, a post from 2004 reproduces an allegedly official statement from Kevin Connor (a longtime Photoshop manager whose name is misspelled in the post). It says, in part:

Photoshop CS does indeed include a counterfeit deterrence system (CDS) to prevent the illegal duplication of banknotes. The CDS was created by a consortium of central banks from around the world. We, along with other hardware and software manufacturers, have included CDS in our products at their request to address the threat posed by the use of digital technologies in the counterfeiting of banknotes. There are other software products from other companies that already use this same technology. There are also hardware products that use the same or similar technology. For example, most color copiers sold today will not allow you to copy currency.

He goes on to explain that “the current implementation of CDS will prevent you from scanning in your own banknotes even if your usage intent is entirely within legal boundaries.” In order to get legal images of banknotes to use, you must obtain them from the US Bureau of Engraving and Printing, or similar bodies in other countries.

But the funny thing about the CDS feature in Photoshop is that it doesn’t appear to always work. After running an admittedly limited number of tests, I came up with mixed results that don’t appear to add up to any cohesive policy.

My photo of a dollar bill in Photoshop. It probably worked because it's not a very good picture.

My photo of a dollar bill in Photoshop. It probably worked because it’s not a very good picture. (click to enlarge)

Photoshop CS6 (version 13.0 x64) would not load images of:

It would load images of:

I was surprised to find that it worked most of the time, rather than the other way around — but there’s clearly much more analysis to be done on how software programs recognize bills; this is a good start for further reading. Luckily, if you’re just resizing images, like I was attempting to originally, Apple Preview seems to have no scruples. If you’re looking for a Photoshop workaround, try (where else?) YouTube.

  • Get Hyperallergic in your Inbox!

    Subscribe to our email newsletter. (Daily or Weekly)

Hyperallergic welcomes comments and a lively discussion, but comments are moderated after being posted. For more details please read our comment policy.
  • websam max

    In the end, somebody really into scanning this will scran part of the note in very hires, and assemble the parts in the end.

    • whycantibeanon

      …or simply use other non-handicapped software for scanning.

  • kevin jannis

    Microsoft Paint to the rescue?

  • wyzellak

    You might be interested in the research on this algorithm. For example,
    http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~sjm217/projects/currency/ and the talk they gave (http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~sjm217/talks/ccc04_counterfeiting.pdf) might be a good starting point.

  • Billy

    Photoshop and Paint Shop Pro both implemented the currency detection in 2003/2004. Saying someone “discovered” this 3 years ago is laughable; it was well publicised over 10 years ago and there were patches available to override it in early Photoshop versions.

    Anyone interested, look up “Counterfeit Deterrence System” and “EURion constellation”.

  • daniël

    I’ve had nothing but great success with the Gimp.

    • Greg

      I was going to ask if this had been tried in GIMP. Sounds like you had success? Not that I want to edit images of bank notes. I’m just curious.

      • loon_attic

        It’s open source so you’d always be able to edit the source and recompile relatively easily to remove any “CDS system”

  • thebleacher

    More info on how they detect bank notes:

  • Barb

    This has been true in copiers for decades. I was told this by the manager of the printshop of the company I worked for in the 80’s and 90’s. No news here.

  • macfixer

    The security is actually pretty widespread…
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation

  • Micky Nozawa

    I thought this was common knowledge, I certainly remember articles about from when Adobe made the change.

  • GFYantiapplezealots

    Apples built-in Image Capture is awesome!

  • point

    Does this detection/prevention not prevent our exercise of free speech? What if I wanted to enlarge a bill to many feet/cm long, and use it in some form of fine art? or political protest?
    Having software do this seems very Big Brother like. Yes, the goal is counterfeit prevention, which I am for but, as a designer trained during the change from pre computer to computer based production, I know both well, I think any real counterfeiter will do it with plates + chemicals and that means camera ready art. Not desktop scans. (This old analog printing tech is probably the best anti counterfeit measure now that it is rare versus common computer based offset print production.)
    If Adobe and MS did this money detector on own, fine. Some over cautious corporate lawyers probably did it. But if implemented by USTD, not good.

    • Doran Zeigler

      You can sometimes reproduce money if it is a lot larger than actual size. Years ago, I did some work for a bank, but we had to get special permission from the Treasury Department. I’m not sure if they still allow this as the paranoia level within the government has increased greatly since then.

  • Becky L

    Can we talk about the BEP’s url moneyfactory.gov?

  • Jon Hall

    Your just finding this out?

  • Zeljko Hrvoj

    Cash counting and authentication machines, like CSI/DLR CPS1500, DLR7000 do this image scanning, corellation, fitness (reflectivity of white) estimation, sorting, with speed of 25 notes per second. On old machines, it’s b/w 100dpi scanning and software is running on Win2000.

  • punktoad

    Try covering the Federal Reserve seal with the FR district letter and you should be able to edit or copy the rest of the bill.

  • gianlucasavini

    Works well with Euro bills

  • Toranosuke

    On a related note, since we’re talking about art and counterfeiting,
    there’s the famous case of Akasegawa Genpei, and the Thousand-Yen Note
    Incident in the 1960s, in which Akasegawa was convicted of
    counterfeiting/forgery for producing (rather blatantly imperfect)
    reproductions of paper money to be used in various ways in art
    production and art practice. Akasegawa passed away late last year, in
    October 2014.

    http://keithwhittle.org/blog/genpei-akasegawas-1000-yen-note-incident/

  • W1titj

    some years ago the Australian government reinstated the Queen’s image on the $5 note. Republicans went nuts.

  • AssetBurned

    The issue is well known and also happens if you try to copy notes on a photo copy machine. The notes are recognised by the EURion constellation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation

  • Just look at the image in Adobe Bridge, then use right mouse button and select “Open with Camera Raw module”, then just open and voila :o)

Previous post:

Next post: