Photo Essays

Whitney Biennial 2014: Stuart Comer on the Third Floor

by Hrag Vartanian on March 5, 2014

The lobby lights of the Whitney Museum (image via Jo Poon's Flickstream)

The lobby lights of the Whitney Museum (image via Jo Poon’s Flickstream)

On the third floor, 2014 Whitney Biennial curator Stuart Comer professed to “provide a kaleidoscopic glimpse of this historic moment,” emphasizing work that seemed in flux and in transition from one medium to another, one state to another, or even across borders and identities.

Zackary Drucker and Rhys Ernst’s Relationship series (2008–13) is the most obvious example, and also the most successful, as the couple documented their relationship as a transgender couple transitioning in opposite directions (Drucker from male to female, Ernest from female to male). The images are intimate, feeling almost alchemical at moments as flashes of light and loving gestures demonstrate a closeness one can only have with a lover. The distance between the two bodies or, in this case, the camera and the subject sometimes feels so close you can almost hear them breathe.

A view of  "Relationship" (2008–13), forty-six chromogenic prints,

A view of Zackary Drucker and Rhys Ernst’s “Relationship” (2008–13), forty-six chromogenic prints (all photos by the author for Hyperallergic unless otherwise noted)

None of the other works on the floor approach that level of magic, except perhaps the ink drawings and abstract works by Etel Adnan. The Lebanese-born artist presents a poetic vision of the world in flux that can feel simultaneously universal and intimate with her simple landscapes and long pages of ink drawings.

Morgan Fisher’s “Ro(Ro(Room)om)om)” (2014) addresses another type of flux, of the Whitney Museum itself, which is in the state of transitioning to another location further downtown. Fisher has taken three distinct spaces from the new, still under-construction building and distorted their scale so that the largest is the smallest and vice versa. The result is a strangely attractive display of the reversal of power. A closet-like form stands in the middle, inaccessible and monolithic like an obelisk surrounded by a stepped plinth. All of the spaces look hollow, like they were abandoned and will never be complete.

Tony Greene, "His Puerile Gestures" (1989), mixed media

Tony Greene, “His Puerile Gestures” (1989), mixed media

This floor also had the misfortune of having some of the worst pieces in the show, most of which looked like frat house hijinks gone wrong. Ken Okiishi’s painted flatscreens and Bjarne Melgaard’s plush, room-sized installation, which incorporates mannequins, projections, and pillows, both look like the remnants of a college rager that resulted in someone turning in the refuse as their art project.

The most perplexing display was the room of paintings by Tony Greene, curated by Richard Hawkins and Catherine Opie. Greene’s work often looked like kitschy paintings in a suburban Italian restaurant, but there were moments of clarity, as in “Untitled (orange pour)” (1990), where you could see the push and pull of desire framed by the thick veneer of sentimentality. Even if I left the room ambivalent about the works, they were some of the most memorable, for better or worse.

Paintings by Keith Mayerson

Paintings by Keith Mayerson

That tension of art that walks the line between bad and good and what criteria we use to make that decision is at the core of two other displays, including a room full of paintings by Keith Mayerson and a display by Triple Canopy. Mayerson’s oil paintings have a breezy sentimental streak, but there’s something attractively self-conscious about them. Triple Canopy focused on systems that circulate objects and images, many of which are banal, but the intellectual structure is fascinating, even if a little dry and academic.

Comer’s role in the Whitney Biennial appeared to be to poke and prod the boundaries between various categories, exploring the state of becoming again and again. That sense of experimentation was most certainly welcome.

whitney3rdfl-01

Two works by Ken Okiishi, both titled “gesture/data” (2013), oil on flatscreen and video transferred on USB flash drive

whitney3rdfl-02

Etel Adnan’s “Champs de Petrol” (2013), wool, overlooking two display cases with her accordion book drawings

12938385245_1efe9b2d60_z

Detail of Etel Adnan, “Untitled” (2013), oil on canvas

Etel Adnan, "New York: From the Triborough Bridge to South of Manhatan, New York, May 21, 1990" (1990), Japanese ink on paper

Etel Adnan, “New York: From the Triborough Bridge to South of Manhatan, New York, May 21, 1990″ (1990), Japanese ink on paper

12938816854_76ee92eaa4_b-640

A 19th-century American painting, “We Go for the Union” (c.1840-50), oil on canvas, in Triple Canopy’s “Pointing Machine” display

12938844794_7f9be33156_z

Paintings (oil on linen) by Keith Mayerson

12938829494_8ee677a907_z

Martin Wong’s “Closed” (1984–85), acrylic on canvas, with a glimpse of Robert Kinmont’s “The wings are in the paper drawer” (1972–73), wood, paper, and Snow Goose wings, at bottom left

12938984085_66d96aeca5_z

A view of an installation by A.L. Steiner and Morgan Fisher’s “Ro(Ro(Room)om)om)” (2014), drywall on metal studs

12938668935_d7f2dfc88c_h-640

Morgan Fisher, “Ro(Ro(Room)om)om)” (2014), drywall on metal studs

12938970865_18b63d7c5a_z

Zackary Drucker and Rhys Ernest, “Relationship” (2008–13), forty-six chromogenic prints, ed. 1/10

12938450825_fd8d06d2f7_z

Detail of Tony Greene’s “Untitled (orange pour)” (1990), mixed media

12938954865_15bc3223b3_z

Detail of Uri Aran, “Untitled” (2014), mixed media

12939067063_54cddf25a0_z

Detail of Uri Aran, “Untitled” (2014), mixed media

12938714655_3725d0c620_z

Artist Ei Arakawa posing in from of his “Hawaiian Presence (Hawaii)” (2014), wire, fabric, straw, and plastic

12938823353_bcb5748451_z

Photo of Jacolby Satterwhite’s “Reifying Desire 6 – Island of Treasure” (2014), high-definition digital 3-D video, color, sound (20 min)

12938513825_62f50fecf7_z

From Bjarne Melgaard’s room-sized installation

12938588163_35b825aa59_b-640

View of one of the mannequins in Bjarne Melgaard’s installation

Another view of Bjarne Melgaard's untitled installation

Another view of Bjarne Melgaard’s untitled installation

12938574813_aa62acc0ec_z

Travis Jeppesen, “Venus of Willendorf/Artist Unknown” (2014), mixed media

12938873294_cd5798ceae_z-1

Fred Lonidler, “GAF Snapshirts” (1976), 32 photo- and text-printed t-shirts

The 2014 Whitney Biennial opens Friday, March 7 at the Whitney Museum (945 Madison Avenue, Upper East Side, Manhattan) and continues until May 25.

  • Subscribe to the Hyperallergic newsletter!

Hyperallergic welcomes comments and a lively discussion, but comments are moderated after being posted. For more details please read our comment policy.
  • andysbasura

    jacolby’s work is god-awful.

Previous post:

Next post: