The fate of the Shukhov Tower, an early architectural tribute to Communist Russia, could be decided by ordinary Moscovites with smartphones. Designed by Constructivist architect Vladimir Shukhov, the radio tower was erected on Lenin’s order in Moscow in 1922 as a monument to the October 1917 Revolution. While encouraging citizens to engage with their cultural patrimony is an exciting trend, it’s a little less so when we’re talking about a poll that could actually lead to the ruin of an architectural icon.
It all started last December, when the newspaper Izvestia quoted Communications Minister Nikolia Nikiforov saying the government planned to dismantle the tower. In the last decade, it had fallen into disrepair, with scraps of rusty metal allegedly flying off in the wind. But citizens protested, taking selfies in front of the structure and signing their names to a petition started by photographer Natalia Melikova.
Moscow officials have since chosen to put the decision to an electronic vote. According to the Moscow Times,
Votes cast using the iPhone and Android application will be “taken into consideration” by the City Hall, according to the description of the vote, which runs through July 6.
The city has a track record of following the outcomes of such polls, despite the fact that the most popular one only drew 335,000 voters from Moscow’s 14 million–strong population. And given the opposition already expressed, it’s a little strange they even need to take a poll at all. In 2006, the renowned architect Norman Foster petitioned UNESCO to add the tower to its World Heritage list. And this past March, the Guardian reported that 38 other architects, including Rem Koolhaas, Tadao Ando, and Kengo Kuma supported the measure. Even Elizabeth Diller — one of the architects involved in the demolition of the American Folk Art Museum, a newer, differently iconic structure whose removal nonetheless solicited similar arguments — backed the appeal.
Regardless, according to the Moscow Times, whoever ventures to vote on the tower’s fate will be able to decide between two possible outcomes:
Options available to voters include refurbishing of the 160-meter “Russian Eiffel Tower,” or dismantling the slowly crumbling hyperboloid structure for repairs, with the possibility of an eventual relocation.
But, as Konstantin Mikhailov of conservationist group Arkhnadzor told the paper, the second option comes despite two independent studies which found that any attempt to dismantle the tower would destroy it. It’s not surprising to learn that some, including the architectural critic Grigory Revzin, see the attempted relocation as a ploy to clear the land for a potential $440 million real estate development.
That a 92-year-old historical landmark could be destroyed if the crowd so chooses has angered some. Vladimir Shukhov Jr., great-grandson of the tower’s creator, told the newspaper, “You just do not poll people on heritage.”
But apparently you do — and not just in Russia. The Louvre has crowdfunded many of its restorations, including, last year, the conservation of its “Winged Victory of Samothrace.” Back in January, Italy crowdsourced the decision as to which of eight pre-selected artworks it should conserve (only 2,326 people voted in that poll, and most of them were women). And in February, the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston also crowd-curated its exhibition Boston Loves Impressionism.
And, hopefully, given Moscovites’ original outraged responses to the proposed dismantling, the Shukhov Tower may still be around for a long, long time.
The 15th edition of the international art exhibition is a gathering of potentialities, a careful alignment of militant particles, and an assembly of thousands of diverse voices.
Ignored and undistributed upon its debut in 1982, in the decades since, the film Losing Ground has slowly gained the recognition it deserves.
Convened by Erika Sprey, Lamin Fofana, Sky Hopinka, Emmy Catedral, and Manuela Moscoso, the public program unfolds this summer at CARA in New York City.
Queer Spaces: An Atlas of LGBTQ+ Places and Stories records how generations of queer communities have persisted and created familial oases around the world.
The uncanny painting by artist Jamie Coreth has prompted speculations of a Dorian Gray-style bargain and drawn comparisons to Madame Tussauds’s wax figures.
The Bay Area art book fair is back this July with free programming at three different on-site venues, new exhibitors, and fundraising editions from renowned artists.
“This contract is a structural breakthrough for museum workers who have been underpaid as a group for years,” said staffer Martina Tanga.
Retrospectives of Chicana artist Amalia Mesa-Bains and Mohawk artist Shelley Niro are among the projects supported by the foundation.
Shows at the Hudson Valley’s Hessel Museum of Art feature artists Dara Birnbaum and Martine Syms, as well as new scholarship on Black melancholia as an artistic and critical practice.
Daniel Weiss, who joined the museum in 2015, led the institution through the turmoil of the pandemic and oversaw milestones like the implementation of paid internships.
Two men were arrested after using a sledgehammer to break a glass display case at the art fair. Police are searching for two more suspects.
The Project of Independence at MoMA probes the limits of modernist construction in South Asia.