LONDON — The term “blockbuster” is defined by the equation: major name or subject + major loans = major ticket sales. Positive critical reception is a valuable though by no means essential by-product. Londoners have been spoilt for choice over the past few months with several blockbusters demanding attention: Vikings at the British Museum, Veronese and Rembrandt at the National Gallery (also to open a major show on Impressionism), and now the Royal Academy is sticking its neck out with Rubens and His Legacy.
Except, while the National flexed its negotiating muscles with superloans from major worldwide collections, and justified its loot with solid curatorial vigor, the Royal Academy’s show — for an artist renowned for his work-by-the-meter-size-canvases — has precious few square meters of Rubens to show, opting to widen its survey to examine his “influence” on art history. This widening is so enthusiastic and expansive that it seems to claim that Rubens influenced seemingly everyone and everything in Western art history, resulting in some worryingly inventive assertions. The exhibition makes extremely tenuous links and comparisons between Rubens and artists as diverse as Watteau, Constable, Turner, Daumier, Corinth, Bacon, Picasso, and Reynolds, right from the 17th century to the present, within themed rooms as academically fluffy as “Lust,” “Power,” “Violence,” “Elegance,” and “Compassion.”
It is an extremely problematic method of display that relies on iconographic content rather than stylistic. In fact, the RA seems so anxious to dispel the common assumption that Rubens was just miles of fat fleshy pink nudes — a lifelong ode to cellulite — that little attention is drawn to arguably his most influential contribution to the history of painting: a prodigious understanding of flesh and its constructive use of hues and fantastic brushwork.
Instead, in the first room, entitled “Poetry,” a landscape sketch by John Constable (!) featuring a rainbow is placed next to a Rubens landscape sketch, also with a rainbow. What deeper analysis are we meant to conclude from this most superficial of comparisons? Little is made of the painterly differences; Constable’s handling of paint, famous for its vibrancy and loose vigor, stands up stylistically — was Rubens’s contribution simply the motif of a rainbow?
Elsewhere, a landscape with a cart descending a hill, “The Harvest Wagon” (1767) by Thomas Gainsborough, is shown next to one by Rubens, also showing a cart descending a hill. The link between the two is not helped by less than watertight assertions made in the accompanying captions: “Gainsborough may have seen Rubens’s ‘The Carters,’ or a copy that was in the collection of Nuneham House, Oxfordshire. He was also almost certainly familiar with the master’s ‘Evening Landscape with Timber Wagon.’” The show is peppered with such vague ties, doing little to progress from simple assertions to clear and definitive evidence of influence.
This type of comparison has more worrying implications in a room entitled “Elegance,” where a series of full-length, three-quarter turned portraits by Anthony van Dyck, Gainsborough, and Sir Joshua Reynolds are placed in sequence with one by Rubens, appearing to suggest that Rubens directly pioneered this type in itself. This absence of explicit and constructive analysis of both style and content between each example of Rubens and the selected paintings enables us to leap to such rash conclusions.
Given the general lack of physical examples of Rubens’s work, it is also unfortunate that the best supported evidence of his significance as a historical figure, found under the theme “Power,” which examines his widely documented and pioneering success as an artist and diplomat, should be represented by videos showing films of his works in situ. Commissioned paintings that acted as propaganda among highly powerful political circles, such as the immense Banqueting House ceiling in Whitehall Palace, London, are visible only in digital projection. Again, we are starved of stylistic evidence with which to draw parallels between this as precedent to the surrounding collection of paintings the RA has selected. Though it is no fault of the RA that several works are attached to buildings, it feels like a last resort in scrabbling for material to present when so little else is available.
A brave step has been taken in commissioning the contemporary painter and Royal Academician Jenny Saville to curate an adjacent room of selected pieces showing “the continuing preoccupations artists share with Rubens … from the treatment of human form and fleshy handling of paint to the use of colour, violence and spectacle.” Finally, the definitive and undeniable influence of Rubens which runs throughout art history like in a stick of rock, is made explicit: the fleshy handling of paint and unflinching depiction of skin and muscle in the nudes of Lucien Freud and Francis Bacon, and even Young British Artist Sarah Lucas’s stuffed tights share the clear visual distinction and mentality of Rubens’s, making for a persuasive and satisfying example of his real, continuing influence in an otherwise severely problematic display. With more significant loans in greater number we might have had the comprehensive and academically satisfying show a real blockbuster usually provides.
Rubens and His Legacy continues at the Royal Academy (Burlington House, Piccadilly, London) through April 10.
Coasting the Topography of South Asian Futurisms
As part of Hyperallergic’s Emily Hall Tremaine Journalism Fellowship for Curators, Sadaf Padder presents an exhibition to offer insight into her curatorial process.
I’m a Florida Drag Queen and I’m Scared
I’m truly at a loss for what to do for work and what kind of life I can expect to live.
Pratt’s 2023 Fine Arts MFA Thesis Exhibition Is On View in Brooklyn
The two-part exhibition features the work of 41 graduating artists across disciplines, including painting, sculpture, printmaking, and integrated practices.
An Artist’s Hopeful Vision of the Ocean
Indonesian artist Mulyana crafts a tactile, mystical world in which fish, whales, and coral reefs coexist with sea monsters.
An Introduction to “Afrogallonism”
Serge Attukwei Clottey explores Ghanaian culture and identity through discarded jerrycans and other found materials.
The Milton Resnick and Pat Passlof Foundation Presents The Feminine in Abstract Painting
Curated by Jennifer Samet and Andrea Belag, this group exhibition in NYC explores the feminine through aesthetics, as opposed to identity or gender.
A Ride With Liz Cohen
Nothing in the artist’s personal biography could predict that she’d one day become a car builder and bikini model.
LA’s Hammer Museum Wants to Be Seen
After two decades of renovations, the museum that calls itself a “well-kept secret” reopens with a mission to be more visible.
NYU Steinhardt Opens 2023 MFA Thesis Exhibitions
Taking place at 80WSE Gallery in New York’s Greenwich Village, Part I is on view from late March through April while Part II opens in May.
AI-Generated “Dope Francis” Fools the Internet
Many thought the picture of Pope Francis in a puffer jacket, created using Midjourney, was the real deal.
1,400-Year-Old Mural of Two-Faced Man Found in Peru
Historians hypothesize that the Moche paintings could represent artists’ attempts to experiment with portraying movement or narrative.
Miniature Worlds: Joseph Cornell, Ray Johnson, Yayoi Kusama
Through small-scale works, this exhibition at the Katonah Museum of Art in New York examines Cornell’s prominent role in the lives and careers of Johnson and Kusama.
Louvre Shutters as Pension Plan Protests Intensify
President Macron’s plan to raise the retirement age from 62 to 64 has sparked widespread demonstrations across the country.
They Managed to Mess Up an Art Heist Movie
There must be a lesson in Vasilis Katsoupis’s film Inside about the vacuousness of the art market or the claustrophobia of exhibition spaces — I just don’t care.
If Peter Paul Rubens had never painted there would never have been a Cecil B. DeMille
He’s just cultivating mass
Will never forget experiencing flesh like no other in the paintings of Jenny Saville at the Brooklyn Museum’s SENSATION show  . . . talk about lust, power, violence, elegance and compassion . . . such attributes might apply to just one square patchwork of her canvas, although that other undefinable magic, call it ‘beauty’ was also there — would love to see this exhibit for her curated room alone.
Comments are closed.