Art

The Enduring Delight of the Diorama

At Palais de Tokyo, selections from nearly two centuries of enclosed models cater to our eagerness to be voyeurs.

Caterina De Julianis, “Santa Maria Maddalena in adorazione della croce” (1717), polychrome wax, painted paper, glass, tempera on paper, and other materials, 53.7 x 59 cm (photo by Artefotografica, Rome; courtesy of Galleria Carlo Virgilio & C, Rome)

PARIS — More than a decade before Louis Daguerre reshaped modern photography with his image of a shoe-shiner working on Paris’s Boulevard du Temple, he’d come to understand that the key to captivating an audience was seducing them with imagined realities.

A painter turned set designer for the Paris Opera, Daguerre excelled at creating sweeping panoramic views of city landscapes. In 1822, he opened the first diorama, a moving-image show that bore little resemblance to the museum displays we know today. He presented a trompe l’oeil spectacle in which a painting appeared to change before viewers’ eyes: Different scenes were painted on each side of a near-transparent canvas, and each would be revealed separately, depending on whether the canvas was lit from the front or the back. Mounted in a special theater that rotated the audience for each view, the diorama was a hit — at least among the wealthy patrons who could afford it — and foreigners flocked to Paris to get a glimpse of the illusions.

Jean-Paul Favand, “Naguère Daguerre I” (2012), view of the canvas illuminated from the front, 19th-century painted canvas, luminous installation and scenography, 270 x 410 cm (photo by Jean Mulatier, courtesy of Jean Paul Favand)
Jean-Paul Favand, “Naguère Daguerre II” (2012), view of the canvas illuminated from the back, 19th-century painted canvas, luminous installation and scenography, 270 x 410 cm (photo by Jean Mulatier, courtesy of Jean Paul Favand)

Only one of Daguerre’s dioramas remains today, but their influence was lasting, as a new exhibit at the Palais de Tokyo in Paris shows. Later interpreters of the diorama — a term that came to encompass miniature models as well as naturalistic scenes of taxidermied animals in museums — knew that viewers wouldn’t be able to resist being fascinated by things they knew were fake. And contemporary artists would bring new life to the form decades later, offering up enclosed concoctions that pandered to our eagerness to be voyeurs.

“Le Bailly” (ca 1740), black cardboard perforated, collaged, colored lining (collection Werner Nekes, Mülheim, photo by Aurélien Mole)
Rowland Ward, “Léopard et guibs harnachés” (1904), wood, bamboo, glass, painted canvas, minerals, plants, plaster, wood, metal, paint, mixed media (Domaine royal de Randan, région Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes)

The most enchanting pieces on view are those that recreate the play of light that characterized Daguerre’s dioramas. In one series from the 18th century, celestial scenes, dense with shooting stars and vaguely Grecian imagery, were cut into cardboard and lit dramatically in warm tones. There’s also a set of delightful miniature painted slides from 1849 that would have been inserted into the Polyorama Panoptique, an optical toy device originally sold as a diorama souvenir. For these, artists made tiny incisions in streetlamps and windows to allow light to pass through, so that in the space of half a minute, a calm afternoon along the Seine would transform into a festive night scene, with fireworks bursting over the river. In another slide, a cathedral bathed in sunlight turns into the scene of a sermon at sunset, with the crowd illuminated by a dazzling, newly emerged chandelier. It’s impossible not to be transfixed by these shifting scenes, and to wonder at the magic of such a simple mechanism marking the passage of time.

Today, dioramas are most closely associated with natural history museums, where lifelike animals are meticulously arranged against a painted backdrop to foster a semblance of reality. Conservationist Carl Akeley, driven by his concern for the survival of gorillas, created the first ones for New York’s Museum of Natural History in 1889. (That institution would later be lampooned in the Ben Stiller movie Night at the Museum, clips of which open and close the Dioramas exhibit.)

Dioramas, installation view (photo by Aurélien Mole)

There’s no shortage of that sort of diorama on display here, including an impressive stuffed albatross by 19th-century taxidermist Rowland Ward, but the works that really stand out are those that wink at the absurdity of dioramas and our modern embrace of sanitized, packaged nature. Water Potter’s “Happy Family” (1870) packs rabbits, puppies, and birds perching on cats’ heads into a house-shaped glass box, making for a rather creepy batch of cute pets. A lone monkey in a scarlet bowtie huddles in a corner, the only one who appears aware of the serious incongruity of the arrangement. Richard Barnes’s photos of museum dioramas after visiting hours — employees cleaning fake snow, a giraffe strung up and ready to go back to storage — similarly puncture the illusion of reality that we’ve willed ourselves into believing.

Richard Barnes, “Man With Buffalo” (2007), archival inkjet print, 137.16 x 167.64 cm (photo courtesy of the artist)
Dulce Pinzón, “Nostalgia, Historias del Paraíso series” (2011), impression, 76.2 x 101.6 cm (photo courtesy of K-Echo Photo, Galéria Patricia Conde, Mexico and H Gallery, Paris)
Walter Potter, “Happy Family” (ca 1870), wood, glass, paint, paper, preserved animals (private collection, photo by Aurélien Mole)

Unsurprisingly, stuffy dioramas gradually fell out of fashion. It didn’t help that far more uncomfortable versions appeared as well: The ethnographic human diorama, which exoticized cultures that had fallen under colonial rule, served as propaganda that reinforced the dominance of the white man.

But in the last few decades, contemporary artists have turned back to the diorama, propelled by its endless ability to fascinate the curious eye. Richard Baquié’s “Étant Donnés” (1991) is a replica of Marcel Duchamp’s final installation, a nude woman lying on twigs with her legs spread open, one hand holding an electric lamp. While Duchamp gave his tableau rather limited viewing points (tiny peepholes in a heavy wooden door), Baquié opens up the space, allowing visitors to walk around — which doesn’t stop them from lining up to squint one by one through the peepholes, the only clear view of the mannequin’s vagina. And steps away, Patrick Jacob’s “Yellow Slime Mold with Blue Pinkgills” (2015), a shrunken vision of mushrooms sprouting out of grass, is built into the exhibit wall and viewable only through a two-inch window, exploiting our insatiable enthrallment with fake realities.

Armand Morin, “Panorama 14” (2013–17), various materials, 260 x 260 x 300 cm (photo courtesy of the artist)
Mark Dion, “Paris Streetscape” (2017), iron, wood, stuffed animals and various materials, 190 x 150 x 250 cm (courtesy of the artist & Galerie In situ – Fabienne Leclerc, Paris, photo by Aurélien Mole)

The exhibit ends, rather ingeniously, with the last scene of The Truman Show, in which Jim Carrey stumbles along the artificial horizon wall that traps him in the reality show that is his life. The curved edges of the shots, echoing those of a television screen, provides a perfect reminder of our obsession with these fictions.

Dioramas continues at Palais de Tokyo (13, avenue du Président Wilson, Paris) through September 10.

comments (0)