Installation view of Rosalba Carriera, "Portrait of a Lady as Diana the Huntress" (circa 1720–1725) in Color into Line: Pastels from the Renaissance to the Present, Legion of Honor, San Francisco (2021) (photo by Gary Sexton, courtesy the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco)

SAN FRANCISCO — When Furio Rinaldi was hired in May 2020 to become the new curator of drawings and prints at the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco (FAMSF), the de Young and Legion of Honor museums were still closed due to COVID-19. Making the best of a bad situation, Rinaldi took a deep dive into FAMSF’s Achenbach Foundation for Graphic Arts collection. What emerged is a satisfying long-look exhibition on the power of pastels from the 16th century to the 21st, mostly drawn from FAMSF’s own permanent collection, along with loans from a handful of others in Northern California. Rarely on display, and even more rarely on loan (Berthe Morisot’s fabulous portrait of her niece, “Blanche,” for example, hasn’t been exhibited since 1896), pastels are the neglected child in the family of painting. An overlooked and even scorned medium — too slight, too bright, too effete, too fun, (too feminine?) — pastels have a PR problem that Color Into Line: Pastels from the Renaissance to the Present at San Francisco’s Legion of Honor goes a long way in correcting.

Jean-Étienne Liotard, “Portrait of a Man and His Dog, possibly Philippe Basset de la Marelle (1709-1779),” pastel over graphite, on five sheets of parchment, mounted on canvas, 44 7/8 x 33 7/8 inches (Fine Arts Museums of San Francsisco, gift of Grace Hamilton Kelham and Leila Hamilton Lewis in memory of their mother Grace Spreckels Hamilton)

The show opens with sober Italian drawings from the 16th century, but quickly pivots to bright Rococo portraits by artists such as Rosalba Carriera and Jean-Étienne Liotard (who both include two very winning dog companions). Ground pigment mixed with a binder to create a colored stick had been in use since the early 16th century to sketch underdrawings for oil paintings, as witnessed by the show’s opening pieces. Artists made such sticks themselves until the mid-17th century when they came into limited production. By the early 18th-century there was an eager market for commercial pastels. Venetian artist Rosalba Carriera — known in her lifetime as “The Queen of Pastel” — helped invigorate that market by pioneering a new style of painting, utilizing pastels.

Pastels have an immediacy and sensuousness perfect for portraiture, Carriera’s most usual subject. The soft powdery surface they leave behind gives richness and texture to fabrics, and when depicting human skin, pastels fur the flesh in a way that’s remarkably lifelike. You sense the little follicles of humanity, the makeup and the dust, the artifice and the natural that comprise us all. No wonder the medium has appealed to so many artist over so many centuries, as Color Into Line elegantly reveals, from 18th-century artists like Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun and her father, Louis Vigée, to 19th-century Impressionist stalwarts such as Manet, Degas, Cassatt, and Gonzales, onto 20th-century names like Redon, Rivera, Mitchell, Diebenkorn, Thiebaud and many more. The exhibition’s most recent piece, a multi-figure pandemic scene by Donna Anderson Kam, was acquired from the de Young Open in late 2020.

Installation view, Color into Line: Pastels from the Renaissance to the Present, Legion of Honor, San Francisco (photo by Gary Sexton, courtesy the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco)

A somewhat understated, but clear through line of the show is the predominance of women artists working in pastel (the reasons are numerous, including portability; no need for smelly solvents; belief that pastels were, like makeup, somehow “natural” to women, etc). There are approximately three women artists included in each gallery, which can feel a little like too-careful tokenism, but on the other hand I can’t think of another exhibition spanning so many centuries that includes so many women artists with ease. It’s time to see women artists incorporated into the broader art historical narrative rather than set apart (and set aside).

Color Into Line is well worth seeing for any number of art historical reasons — a quick primer on European art from the Renaissance to today; the reevaluation of a significant medium; the reinsertion of women artists into the canon. But maybe most significantly, pastels are damned beautiful. They’re lush, radiating color and quickness and energy. A kind of eye candy, they are an indulgence for the senses. Pastels can offer pure pleasure, which is in short supply.

Mary Cassatt, “Bust of a Young Woman” (ca. 1885–1890), pastel on gray discolored paper, 17 7/8 x 15 3/16 inches (Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco, Achenbach Foundation for Graphic Arts, Memorial gift from Dr. T. Edward and Tullah Hanley, Bedford, Pennsylvania)

Color Into Line: Pastels from the Renaissance to the Present continues at the Legion of Honor Museum (100 34th Avenue, San Francisco) through February 13, 2022. The exhibition was curated by Furio Rinaldi.

The Latest

Required Reading

This week, Godard’s anti-imperialism, in defense of “bad” curating, an inexplicable statue, criminalizing culture wars, and more.

Bridget Quinn

Bridget Quinn is a writer, critic and art historian living in San Francisco. She’s the author of She Votes: How U.S. Women Won Suffrage, and What Happened Next, illustrated by 100 women artists,...

One reply on “Pastels Are Damned Beautiful”

  1. Thank you for this article. The show sounds glorious! And so good to see an exhibition drawn heavily from a museum’s own collection – like shopping your closet. It’s an important resource for many reasons and hopefully the trend will continue.
    I would like to point out that pastel artworks are more problematic to exhibit as their delicate surface requires that they be transported flat. Vibrations from travel are a real risk. Additionally, they must be glazed under glass, not plexiglas (which creates a magnetic field that can lift the dust), so large works are quite heavy. These two factors can make pastel works less likely to be shown and certainly less likely to be included in loan shows.

Comments are closed.