Sculpture of Homeless Jesus Sparks Controversy

by Jillian Steinhauer on April 15, 2014

Timothy Schmalz's “Homeless Jesus” in Davidson, North Carolina (all images courtesy the artist)

Timothy Schmalz’s “Homeless Jesus” in Davidson, North Carolina (all images courtesy the artist)

When it comes to religious art, depictions of Jesus tend to feature him as saintly, reverential, floating above mere mortals or healing them with his touch (or he’s a baby). But a sculpture by artist Timothy P. Schmalz shows Jesus as a homeless man wrapped in a blanket, asleep on a bench.

The life-size bronze work is titled, appropriately, “Homeless Jesus,” according to the artist’s website, and an edition of it has been installed in Davidson, North Carolina, by the local St. Alban’s Episcopal Church, which received the statue as a memorial for a parishioner “who loved public art,” writes NPR. Predictably, some residents are less than thrilled about the thought-provoking work — one woman called the police the first time she saw it, explaining, “I was concerned for the safety of the neighborhood.” Others have said that “Homeless Jesus” creeps them out or insults them.

Pope Francis with the model for "Homeless Jesus"

Pope Francis with the model for “Homeless Jesus”

On his website, Schmalz writes that the sculpture was inspired by Matthew 25 and explains the religious intention behind all of his work: “I am devoted to creating artwork that glorifies Christ. … I describe my sculptures as being visual prayers” (including against abortion). St. Alban’s rector, the Rev. David Buck, stands by “Homeless Jesus” and the message it sends, and he’s in good company: last fall Schmalz presented the wooden model for the work to Pope Francis, who prayed over and blessed it. (Do I see a candidate for the Holy See pavilion at the 2015 Venice Biennale?)

Other Christian organizations are interested, too: a version was placed outdoors at the University of Toronto’s Regis College last spring, and Chicago’s Catholic Charities are hoping to purchase and install a version, the Chicago Tribune reported, although the cost may prevent them. The price — $35,000 according to the Tribune, though the NC version was bought for $22,000, says NPR — apparently deterred the rectors of St. Michael’s Cathedral in Toronto and St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York from purchasing versions of the sculpture in the past.

Naturally, critics have been quick to latch onto the price. A blogger on the conservative site Wizbang discussed “the actions of an Episcopal Church in North Carolina that wasted $22,000 on a metal statue of a ‘homeless Jesus’ to make a political statement instead of spending that money on, well, you know, the homeless.” Since the sculpture was given as a gift to the congregation, this argument doesn’t actually hold water, but it raises the interesting question of how art fits into the larger scheme of religious organizations, and at what cost. How do you value in dollars the potential inspiration of reflection and prayer?

My favorite criticism of “Homeless Jesus,” though, comes from local resident Jerry Dawson. In a letter to the editor of community site, Dawson writes:

My complaint is not about the art-worthiness or the meaning behind the sculpture. It is about people driving into our beautiful, reasonably upscale neighborhood and seeing an ugly homeless person sleeping on a park bench.

Clearly St. Alban’s has some work left to do.

  • Get Hyperallergic in your Inbox!

    Subscribe to our email newsletter. (Daily or Weekly)

Hyperallergic welcomes comments and a lively discussion, but comments are moderated after being posted. For more details please read our comment policy.
  • Chris Egan

    Did Jesus get called an ugly homeless person?

    • kgbmine1

      Oh yes that sick man did! the only ugly is the man calling it ugly what a disgrace is he isn’t he?!!!!

  • thorn

    $22,000. for the piece
    is a bargain–the work is priceless!
    Bless the artist, the N.C. Episcopal Church and the Pope.
    It’s brilliant and enough to make me religious (again)!

  • marie

    As a Christian, I think this is great. A tribute to and reminder of Matthew 25. I think it’s a wonderful message that people of all faiths can appreciate – to care for others, the needy, the sick, the less fortunate. That we’re all one.

  • Eddie Arroyo

    Finally a good religious piece of contemporary art. I mean its not Piss Christ or the Virgin Mary made of cow dung but its a good start. If anyone has other recommendations of relevant religious contemporary art please comment. I am curious to make some notations on it.

  • Chicken_Fingers

    Lots of Christians can’t recognize their own Christ, and I say this as a Christian.

  • Apelles1

    Fascinating how far we have come in the other direction, in the Middle Ages this would not be controversial at all, Mendicant Orders such as the Franciscans and the Poor Clares devoted their religious practices to these principles.

  • Donald Catton

    In no way can a completely drapped figure called a depiction of Christ, Iconographicly this in an unsupportable invention of the Artist, anyway, Christ can not be concieved as homeless because his home was not here.

  • Linda Ann Puetz

    Who said homeless people are ugly?

    • kgbmine1

      very well said…this is a man that has no respect for himself for human life at all!!!he has no compassion and those people in this world are the ones that are ugly-believe this man is the true definition of ugly-

  • kgbmine1

    Simply disgusting how people can take the true meaning of this sculpture and turn it’s beauty into disgrace…you people should be thinking and real hard WWJD!!! How many times have you just passed a homeless person and thought of them in a negative way instead of bringing them a sandwich and something to drink?!!! this world needs to learn COMPASSION!!! thank you for making this sculpture..and to the man who called it ugly maybe you should look within yourself..the only ugliness I see is the people calling it ugly…

Previous post:

Next post: