Articles

Why Won’t the MTA Allow This Artist to Make Art? [UPDATE]

by Mostafa Heddaya on May 16, 2013

Enrico Miguel Thomas in his Red Hook studio. (all photographs by the author for Hyperallergic)

Enrico Miguel Thomas in his Red Hook studio. (all photographs by the author for Hyperallergic)

A few months ago, on a February evening in Grand Central, Brooklyn-based artist Enrico Miguel Thomas carried his drawing board a few paces away from where he had been set up, illustrating from a counter  — leaving behind a bag full of markers and a folded-up easel. After a brief moment of gathering the necessary detail on his subject, a process he characterizes as having taken no longer than five minutes, he turned to find a swarm of police officers gathering near his bags, which were less than ten feet away. After approaching the officers, claiming the bags, and identifying himself as an artist, the MTA police insisted on “clearing” his property with a K-9 bomb-sniffing dog.

Enrico Miguel Thomas, who has spent the better part of the last decade doing subway illustrations, was irked by the exchange, but his displeasure turned to shock when a single officer stayed behind and handed him a pink summons for “dis-con,” or Disorderly Conduct. The incident has since developed into a bizarre legal process, as reported by the New York Times on Monday, and yesterday Hyperallergic was able to catch up with the artist at his Red Hook studio to learn more about his practice and his relationship with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

photo 5

A drawing of commuters in Grand Central.

This wasn’t Mr. Thomas’s first brush with MTA authorities — in 2010, he had been cited for obstructing passengers, a charge he successfully defeated in court after an eight month ordeal. More recently, in July 2012, he had been invited by the MTA’s Transit Museum to lead a workshop for kids about his work as one of the most recognizable artists working on New York’s iconic transportation infrastructure: the subway.

His works, which have previously earned him recognition in the New York Times, center around illustrations of New York and subway scenes — passengers, trains, landmarks — drawn with permanent markers on the subway maps distributed by the MTA. And so it was especially painful for Enrico Miguel Thomas to find himself again at odds with the very institution that inspires his work, and to find himself the target of what he considers to be a discriminatory attitude, both against his heritage — he’s Puerto Rican and African American — and his position as an artist.

photo (5)

The Fifth Avenue Apple Store, as envisioned by Enrico Miguel Thomas. (click to enlarge)

“He’s still there,” Mr. Thomas recounted overhearing the officers telling each other after they cleared his bags. Even though he repeatedly showed them clips of his press coverage to explain his presence at Grand Central, the officers allegedly were irritated by his unwillingness to take off and decision to continue drawing after the incident. After he received the summons, he told Hyperallergic, he was so upset that he left the terminal immediately, and the piece he was working on that evening remained unfinished.

There is a legitimate policing function to the MTAPD, but repeatedly harassing a quiet, unobtrusive artist who has dedicated his work to contemplative drawings inspired by New York infrastructure seems a bit excessive. The world’s subway systems are defined by the community of buskers and assorted artists who variously pander to, document, and gently disrupt the commuter tedium.

Regardless of how one might feel about New York’s increasingly tight security apparatus, the chilling effect on artistic expression is palpable, and Enrico Miguel Thomas’s double-edged experience — his previous experience getting an MTA citation overturned and his invited participation at the Transit Museum — suggest that there is a disconnect between how the MTA presents itself in public and how it enforces, to a draconian extent, rules and regulations meant to curtail criminal behavior rather than harmless expression.

After the incident, Mr. Thomas eventually found a lawyer, and, like his previous imbroglio with the MTA, planned to fight the charges. At a Midtown Community Court hearing on May 1, the judge, Felicia Mennin, offered up a shocking rationale for the Disorderly Conduct citation — in upholding the summons, she referred not to legal precedent but the Boston Marathon bombings and 9/11 in justifying the encroachment on Thomas’s rights. Her comments spurred the New York Times coverage mentioned above, and are demonstrative of the petty fascism of Manhattan’s minor courts. Despite the decidedly prosaic legal process ahead, Thomas remains inspired: though his previous work had taken him all over the city, he has found himself increasingly drawn to Grand Central since the incident. “I’m going back nearly every day, now my Grand Central collection is staggering.”

Update, 6/27: Enrico Miguel Thomas has written in to let us know that “the case was dismissed because the accusing officer was a no-show.”

  • Subscribe to the Hyperallergic newsletter!

Hyperallergic welcomes comments and a lively discussion, but comments are moderated after being posted. For more details please read our comment policy.
  • http://www.facebook.com/matthewwlangley Matthew Langley

    is there a way to help? Let us know if there is a fund or donation point.

  • thom thom

    “New York’s increasingly tight security apparatus” sums it up pretty well. I don’t believe NYC has lost all of its culture, but NYC has been changing into a stale version of itself ever since Giuliani decided to clean up Times Square. Every time I think NYC is finished cleaning itself up and making the world safe for fuck knows what they try cleaning it up more only to sweep away every ounce of culture hiding in the corners in the process. All that is left is people ranting and bitching about a shitty fashion show at the Met. It’s sad that so many people pay close attention to the Met. Fuck the Met seriously.

    It’s great the dealers are off the corners and crime is down since the early 90′s but why get rid of the hotdog vendors, musicians, artists, and freaks. I liked these people. I have to ride my bike long distances now to find them. The sidewalks are boring. People go along with it to protect their freedoms.

  • just1more

    The massive, highly secretive security infrastructure is working hard at profiling, harassing and trampling on the civil rights of the public in general, and minorities in particular. Great job everyone.

  • http://jdsiazon.com/ JD Siazon

    I completely agree with the judge in that modern terrorism is real because the people of Boston can testify to it and so can the deceased of 9/11.

    I cannot believe that Enrico’s work has received kudos from the art machine! Its angle is tourist exploitation at its educative best while its quality rivals the best elementary school work give or take the “avenue gimmicks.”

    I was somewhat friends with Enrico once … Tout him at the grave peril of your credibility and burgeoning career.

    Mr. Heddaya, it would do you well to reflect awhile on the ignominious politics of your tirade before jumping on some journalistic bandwagon of mental ease and professional stability.

    You brazenly spit on the carcasses of innocents to uphold the principles of an art machine which before had you lustily hypnotized but now mysteriously spelling its venom?

  • Zo

    I had a similar experience–not as extreme–in Toronto, when I was doing an assignment for my contemporary Canadain architecture course in the financial district, taking photographs, doing sketches and making notes of the financial buildings. It didn’t help that it was right before the infamous G20 summit. I was repeatedly approached and interrogated by bank security personnel (I was taken to a basement and was held there for at least an hour) and by law enforcement officers on the street, and they took down my identification information. They almost flipped when I explained I was doing this for a school assignment and that 40+ students have already come and gone and done the same thing!

Previous post:

Next post: