In a trend piece two months ago that caused much snickering on the internet, the New York Times wrote that creative New Yorkers are peacing out and heading west to Los Angeles, which the article heralded as a “bohemian paradise.” Even before that piece, David Byrne and Moby had given their reasons why New York is losing its status as a “cultural capital” and becoming increasingly infertile for creativity. But a new report that closely examines New York City’s creative sector argues otherwise, providing recent statistics suggesting that Gotham’s still got it as the nation’s cultural center, and that its arts sector has actually been thriving for the past decade.
Titled “Creative New York,” the 68-page report was written by Adam Forman of the Center for an Urban Future and draws its conclusions from not only census data, various surveys, and research reports, but also conversations with over 150 creative professionals, government officials, donors to the arts, and others. (Full disclosure: Hyperallergic’s editor-in-chief Hrag Vartanian was among those interviewed.) In 2013, the study notes, 8.6% of the nation’s creative workforce was based in New York City, a jump from 7.1% in 2003. This increased share, impressive considering that the city accounts for 3% of all jobs in the US, also signals New York’s replacement of LA as the country’s largest site of creative business employment. Furthermore, every industry in New York City’s creative sector — defined in the report as individuals, commercial, and nonprofit businesses “involved in all stages of the creative process, from conception through production to presentation” — increased in share of national employment between 2003 and 2013. In fact, New York’s creative sector outpaced not only those of its rival cities but also the more traditional sectors of its own economy: over the last decade, the city’s creative workforce as a whole reflected a greater growth than employment in its finance, insurance, legal, and real estate sectors.
Paralleling this growth is the proliferation and expansion of sites to enjoy art; according to the report, the number of art and cultural festivals has skyrocketed, exemplified by NYCxDesign’s 2012 debut and the New York Philharmonic’s first biennial last year. New York City is also home to more arts-related nonprofits than any other US city, and theaters and museums have witnessed major expansions, too (for instance, the new Whitney Museum). In terms of smaller art businesses, the number of galleries city-wide jumped as well: between 2004 and 2015, the total number rose from 1,138 to 1,384 — although 310 have also shuttered since 2011.
The study does emphasize that continued growth is not guaranteed. In their essays, Byrne and Moby both cursed New York primarily for its ever-worsening economic inequality, and affordability is obviously a major factor in sustaining a thriving arts hub. As “Creative New York” attests, working and living in the city is “crushingly expensive,” and taking a closer look at the shifting gallery numbers in terms of geographic distribution makes this clear. While the total number in the five boroughs rose, Manhattan witnessed an overall decrease in galleries. Some spaces relocated within the borough, which sheds some light on affordability by neighborhood: 20% and 43% drops in West Chelsea and Soho spaces, respectively, were mirrored by a 147% increase in the Lower East Side.
“Retail prices ten years ago would have been $12 to $25 per square foot,” real estate agent Anne-Brigitte Sirois says in the report. “Chelsea is now out of reach for 90% of established galleries in NYC.” Looking eastward to Brooklyn, the number of galleries there has soared since 2004 from 95 to 248, primarily in Bushwick, Dumbo, and Greenpoint.
The report notes that housing in the city’s creative neighborhoods also reflects skyrocketing rents. In the ten community districts “most closely associated with art and creativity,” rents rose by at least 32% from 2000 to 2012; the median increase across all districts for the same period was 23%. Looking just at Manhattan, housing costs there exceed those in every other arts-rich city by over 100% — for instance, Manhattan housing costs 114% more than housing in Los Angeles, 473% more than in Nashville. As playwright and puppeteer Robin Frohardt told the researchers in a particularly bleak quotation: “The speed at which rents are rising, there won’t be any artists here in 20 years.”
Wage-wise, the situation seems encouraging at the surface, with New York’s creative workers earning 44% more than the national average. However, once the study factors in the cost of living in the Big Apple, the median hourly wage is actually 15% less than the national average. Sources of revenue such as government funding help artists realize their projects, but they are reportedly in decline: support from the New York State Council on the Arts, for example, fell from $30 million in 2008 to $21 million this year. On the other hand, individual philanthropy is on the rise, and an impressive 36% of Manhattan households donate to creative endeavors. Additionally, crowd-funding efforts are playing increasingly significant roles, especially in New York City. Interestingly, the report states that in “every creative field, New York City-based Kickstarter projects were more successful at reaching their fundraising goal than those based in other places around the world.” (Another fun fact: there are more Etsy sellers in New York City than yellow cab drivers.) More and more, artists have also formed collectives and created shared spaces as ways to reduce costs. Eyebeam, Pioneer Works, and the Con Artist Collective are just a few of the creative collaborations to emerge in recent years, the study notes.
To improve the state of the arts in the city, Mayor Bill de Blasio has announced various initiatives since taking office, which “Creative New York” does mention. However, as the report points out, there is much more to be done. The last section of the study provides more than 20 comprehensive recommendations for the de Blasio administration to help tackle the challenges outlined in the previous pages. These include calls for even more affordable living and working spaces with fewer bureaucratic hurdles during application processes; an outline of possible sources of government funding to support cultural programs and organizations; and suggestions to ensure that the creative sector is all-inclusive and fair to immigrant, low-income, and youth or student communities. As “Creative New York” shows, the arts sector is one of the city’s most valuable assets; why not work toward sustaining its vitality so that New York remains, as Byrne still believed in 2013, “the most stimulating and exciting place in the world to live and work”?
Did You Know These Museums Were Free for New Yorkers?
The “Free Admission” campaign is advocating to make ticket pricing information more transparent to visitors, who may be confused or misled by institutions’ language.
AI Images Visualizing Trump’s Arrest Send Internet Into a Frenzy
The pictures, created using Midjourney, depict the former president’s greatest fantasy: being dragged away by police in front of the cameras.
Haggerty Museum of Art Presents Tomás Saraceno in Dialogue With Dr. Somesh Roy
The artist and researcher will explore soot’s effects on climate change and public health in this online conversation.
Some AI Artworks Now Eligible for Copyright
New guidance from the US Copyright Office sets some policies around AI-generated images.
NYC Hispanic Society Workers to Strike Indefinitely
One worker said the museum’s “skeletal” workforce bars the institution from functioning to its potential.
McKnight Visual Artist Fellows Discussion Series at the Minneapolis Institute of Art
The series features 2021 Fellows David Bowen, Mara Duvra, Rotem Tamir, Ben Moren, and Dyani White Hawk in conversation with renowned curators and critics.
In Search of Inclusive South Asian Futurisms
We have been dangerously siloed for far too long by colonial constructs of race, nation, and time that separate, divide, and deny us our very being.
What Do Shtreimels and Cowboy Hats Have in Common?
A chance meeting on the subway introduced photographer Francesca Magnani to the multicultural world of Brooklyn milliner Richard Faison.
Nevada Museum of Art Presents Adaline Kent: The Click of Authenticity
For the first time in nearly 60 years, the innovative yet under-recognized artist is the subject of a retrospective exhibition. On view in Reno, Nevada.
Richard Hull Completes the Picture
Once known for his abstracted portraits, the Chicago artist is now exploring new directions.
You Too Can Have Your Art on a Postage Stamp
The process isn’t complicated, and thousands of people submit themselves for the talent pool every year.
The Public Theater in NYC Presents Plays for the Plague Year
Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Suzan-Lori Parks’s theatrical concert chronicles the 2020 lockdown and the hope and perseverance that emerged from it.
Bobby Wilson Combats Indigenous Stereotypes Through Humor
The artist-performer’s career undulates, ever so gracefully, across multiple mediums and registers of generational pain, healing laughter, and Indigenous joy.
Rare 19th-Century Silhouette Album’s Secrets Unlocked
Traveling portrait artist William Bache’s album depicts famous figures like Thomas Jefferson as well as people whose identity was previously unknown.
I like David Byrne, but he ain’t statistician.
I am in LA now : )
New York / Toronto the New York of the North “Creative Sector” is thriving for white people, the creative sector/advertising agency sector is the most racists industry in North America. So-called White Creatives has completely locked out black people from the Ad agency world. We have White gays like Richard Florida writing books about the Creative Class and not mentioning ONE word about the most creative class of people in the world…. Black people!!!. he talks about the importance of having white gays in ones neighborhood to make it culturally cool but nothing about the people who actually create black/western culture…do you think the fact that Richard Florida is a white gay guy have any thing to do with the fact that he thinks white gays are cool and required to have a hip neighborhood/ city?.
How about an article documenting the rampant anti-black racism in New York and Toronto’s “Creative sector” that locks out the most creative people in the world?. Its so bad in Toronto that not even Author Malcolm Gladwell could get a job as a lowly copywriter in the Great White North!! .. he had to flee to New York where he got a shot and the rest is history.
I believe 95% of the people working in the Ad industry in New York are white. In Toronto its probably 99%.. Why do white people have to have ALL the Great Jobs?in cities where they are in the minority?.. some thing is wrong with this picture and its stinks to high heaven!!
Comments are closed.