Books

The Forgotten Artistic Playgrounds of the 20th Century

Group Ludic, Playground for La Grande Delle, Hérouville-Saint-Clair (ZUP Ville Nouvelle), France (1968) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for La Grande Delle, Hérouville-Saint-Clair (ZUP Ville Nouvelle), France (1968) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)

No matter if your childhood playground had a rusted metal slide that was scorching hot in summer or a sleek and safe structure of soft plastic climbing walls and swings, it’s likely that you created your own narrative of play. Maybe the jungle gym was a pirate ship, or the slide a mountain, but grownups watching only saw chaos.

Cover of 'The Playground Project' (courtesy JRP-Ringier)
Cover of ‘The Playground Project’ (courtesy JRP-Ringier) (click to enlarge)

Following World War II, and up to stricter playground regulations in the 1980s, artists, architects, and designers imagined new playgrounds that fostered this fluid creativity. Rather than equipment with implied actions (like a slide), they built abstract, climbable sculptures, landscapes of peaks and tunnels, and sometimes just concoctions of debris in a vacant lot where children could build whatever environment they desired. These “adventure playgrounds” contrasted to the sort of holding-pen playgrounds of the 19th century that arose with the social reform movement. And in Europe, where many cities were pocked with postwar rubble, adventure playgrounds could be temporarily installed in these vacant lots, utilizing their raw materials. Landscape architect Marjory Allen in London, for instance, was an advocate for adventure playgrounds, including one at a bomb site at Clydesdale Road in 1952. Meanwhile in the United States, the sprawl of the suburbs, and decline of urban downtowns, required a new perspective on designing vibrant public space.

The Playground Project, out now with essays in German and English from JRP-Ringier, explores this era of artistic play. Edited by city planner Gabriela Burkhalter, the publication developed from her years of research on this overlooked history (which you can also explore online). Burkhalter curated a 2013 show on playgrounds at Pittsburgh’s Carnegie Museum of Art, which evolved into the larger Playground Project exhibition now at Kunsthalle Zürich. Burkhalter writes that as “hardly anyone sees playgrounds as part of their cultural heritage, much of their history has been forgotten.” She adds that there have been “four paradigm shifts” in the playground over the past 150 years:

First, at the beginning of the 20th century, social reformers took children off the street and onto the playground. Then, at the beginning of the 1930s, the idea arose that children should play with natural materials rather than playground equipment. In the 1960s, the decade of autonomy and do-it-yourself, parents, children, and neighborhood groups began to take charge of playgrounds themselves. Finally, in the 1980s, with the end of social and political utopias, a crisis in playground design began.

Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort, Biguglia (V.V.F), Korsika / Corsica (1972) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort, Biguglia (V.V.F), Korsika / Corsica (1972) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Niki de Saint Phalle's "Golem" (1972) slide in Jerusalem's Rabinovich Park (1990 photo by Nathan Alpert/Wikimedia)
Niki de Saint Phalle’s “Golem” (1972) slide in Jerusalem’s Rabinovich Park (1990 photo by Nathan Alpert/Wikimedia)

Photographer Brenda Biondo, in discussing her 2014 book Once Upon a Playground: A Celebration of Classic American Playgrounds, 1920-1975, echoed the assertion that this aspect of the built environment hasn’t been widely considered. “So many Americans grew up playing on this stuff, and it’s a part of Americana, but nobody was documenting it, nobody was collecting it,” she told Hyperallergic.

Group Ludic, Workshop, Foyer Réimois, Reims, France (1973) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Workshop, Foyer Réimois, Reims, France (1973) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle) (click to enlarge)

So why should we care about the playground? As Burkhalter argues in The Playground Project, playgrounds are a meeting point of both modernism and a distinctly 20th-century perspective on childhood. From boxer, sculptor, and Princeton University professor Joseph Brown’s spiderweb structures of ropes and springs that encouraged collaborative play, to the interconnected orbs made from recycled materials by Group Ludic in France, playgrounds were also a global movement in radically rethinking public space.

Many playground designers were inspired by sculptor Isamu Noguchi. Although none of the New York City playgrounds he started designing in the 1930s were realized — due in large part to Parks Commissioner Robert Moses who preferred his own repeating metal bar-based playgrounds — Noguchi’s concepts of sculptural environments influenced later figures like Richard Dattner. Dattner’s five 1960s to ’70s playgrounds, built in a post-Moses New York, endure with their interactive landscapes in Central Park, albeit renovated for a newly litigious age. Burkhalter notes that they’ve “lost much of their original idiosyncrasy when they were adapted to meet contemporary security standards; for example, tactile sand was replaced by a soft plastic surface.” Landscape architect M. Paul Friedberg was likewise inspired by Noguchi in erecting playgrounds with the New York Housing Authority, such as the rambling hills of stone and concrete at the Jacob Riis Houses and a climbable sculpture at the Carver Houses in Spanish Harlem, rather than the originally planned untouchable piece of art.

Pages from 'The Playground Project' (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
Playground by Isamu Noguchi in ‘The Playground Project’ (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
Isamu Noguchi's Playscapes in Piedmont Park, Atlanta (photo by Terren in Virginia/Flickr)
Isamu Noguchi’s 1976 “Playscapes” in Piedmont Park, Atlanta (photo by Terren in Virginia/Flickr)

Noguchi finally had his first American playground completed in 1976 with “Playscapes” in Atlanta, commissioned by the High Museum of Art. This collaboration between institutions and artists was essential for making art playgrounds a reality, with groups such as Creative Playthings involving artists like Danish sculptor Egon Möller-Nielsen in the 1950s to produce playground sculptures available to order from catalogues, even coordinating a play sculpture competition with the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in 1954. Richard W. Crawford, Philadelphia’s Commissioner of Recreation, led the installation of several play sculptures by Möller-Nielsen and others in his city. Even the much smaller municipality of my hometown, Bartlesville, Oklahoma, commissioned architect Bruce Goff to build the recently restored 1963 “Play Tower,” based on the idea of a Möbius strip, with an accompanying climbable sculpture alongside. Children were encouraged to run up and down the stairs of the Space Age-styled tower, making as much noise as possible to rattle its steel cage.

“The abstract playground sculptures fit the mood of the age, which wanted to promote creativity in children,” Burkhalter writes. “The supply grew, and soon it was good form for city governments to install playground sculptures, even if mass production led to more and more banal designs.”

Egon Möller-Nielsen's "The Egg (Ägget)" in Stockholm (photo by Bengt Oberger/Wikimedia)
Egon Möller-Nielsen’s “The Egg (Ägget)” in Stockholm (photo by Bengt Oberger/Wikimedia)
Group Ludic, Playground for Les Logis du Clapet, Royan, France (1969) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for Les Logis du Clapet, Royan, France (1969) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)

Playgrounds today don’t have that same freedom of experimentation, especially since the 1981 publication of the US Consumer Safety Commission’s Guidelines for Playground Safety. Yet there is a recent revival of interest in art playgrounds. Last year’s The Brutalist Playground at the Royal Institute of British Architects involved a playscape designed by Assemble and artist Simon Terrill that celebrated the postwar playground landscape. And an adventure playground recently had a successful Kickstarter campaign to be constructed in New York.

None of these individual projects is quite like what happened in the mid-20th century, when the playground, from Japan to Stockholm, was reborn as a place of artistic experimentation. Children in some ways have different lives today, often much more structured after-school activities, with free time frequently filled with passive activities on digital devices. Still, the innovative ideas presented in The Playground Project respond to the universal enthusiasm in children for play, and show that even just a well-placed corner filled with sand, or a sculpture you can crawl into rather than keep behind barriers can make public space an active part of children’s lives.

Group Ludic, Adventure playground Chalons-sur-Saône, France (1973) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Adventure playground Chalons-sur-Saône, France (1973) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Slide by Josef Schagerl in Vienna (photo by Michael Kranewitter/Wikimedia)
Slide by Josef Schagerl in Vienna (photo by Michael Kranewitter/Wikimedia)
Work by M. Paul Friedberg in 'The Playground Project' (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
Work by M. Paul Friedberg in ‘The Playground Project’ (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
Playground designed by Aldo van Eyck in Amsterdam (photo by MartinStevens/Wikimedia)
Playground designed by Aldo van Eyck in Amsterdam (photo by MartinStevens/Wikimedia)
Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort La Grande Motte, France (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort La Grande Motte, France (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Pages from 'The Playground Project' (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
Playground by Aldo van Eyck in Amsterdam in ‘The Playground Project’ (photo of the book for Hyperallergic)
The Heckscher Playground designed by Richard Dattner in 1969 and 1972, and later renovated by the Central Park Conservancy in 2005 (photo by MusikAnimal/Wikimedia)
The Heckscher Playground designed by Richard Dattner in 1969 and 1972, and later renovated by the Central Park Conservancy in 2005 (photo by MusikAnimal/Wikimedia)
Group Ludic, Blijdorp Park, Rotterdam, Commission De Bijenkorf (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Blijdorp Park, Rotterdam, Commission De Bijenkorf (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort, Anglet (V.V.F),  France (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)
Group Ludic, Playground for family holiday resort, Anglet (V.V.F),  France (1970) (courtesy of Xavier de la Salle)

The Playground Project is out now from JRP-Ringier. The Playground Project continues at Kunsthalle Zürich (Limmatstrasse 270, Zürich, Switzerland) through May 15.

comments (0)