It’s been the better part of a decade since Naruto, a Celebes crested macaque living on the Indonesian island of Sulawesi, snapped a photo of himself using wildlife photographer’s David Slater camera, setting in motion the so-called “Monkey Selfie” legal saga. Yesterday, the Ninth Circuit court of appeals delivered what may prove to be the final decision in that case, siding with Slater, dismissing the lawsuit brought on behalf of Naruto by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), and ruling “that this monkey — and all animals, since they are not human — lacks statutory standing under the Copyright Act.”
Last year, Slater and PETA had reached an apparent settlement in the dispute, with the photographer agreeing to donate 25% of his revenue from the use and sale of the images of Naruto to charities working to protect crested macaques habitats in Indonesia. However, the Ninth Circuit denied the ensuing petition to dismiss the appeals case, setting the stage for yesterday’s ruling.
“The Copyright Act does not expressly authorize animals to file copyright infringement suits under the statute,” Judge Carlos T. Bea wrote in the three-judge panel’s opinion. “Therefore […] Naruto lacks statutory standing to sue under the Copyright Act.”
Another member of the panel, Judge N. Randy Smith, added a partially concurring opinion, arguing that the case should be dismissed because “next friend” status — the legal relationship PETA claimed to Naruto in its lawsuit on the monkey’s behalf — cannot apply to animals.
“Animal-next-friend standing is particularly susceptible to abuse,” Judge Smith wrote. “Institutional actors could simply claim some form of relationship to the animal or object to obtain standing and use it to advance their own institutional goals with no means to curtail those actions. We have no idea whether animals or objects wish to own copyrights or open bank accounts to hold their royalties from sales of pictures.” The Ninth Circuit ruling upholds the decision of a federal judge to dismiss the case in 2016, which PETA appealed.
“Today, the court reaffirmed that nonhuman animals have the constitutional right to bring a case to federal court when they’ve been wronged,” PETA’s general counsel Jeff Kerr said in a statement, “but the opinion still missed the point, which was that Naruto the macaque undeniably took the photos, and denying him the right to sue under the US Copyright Act emphasizes what PETA has argued all along — that he is discriminated against simply because he’s a nonhuman animal.”
Kerr added that, regardless of the Ninth Circuit panel’s decision, the terms of PETA’s agreement with Slater still stand: “25% percent of the gross proceeds from the photos that Naruto took will go toward supporting him and his community — representing the first time that an animal will obtain a direct financial benefit from something that he or she created.”
As Courthouse News points out, the three-judge panel’s opinion does not address some of the case’s potentially more far-reaching issues, such as whether or not a human can own copyrights of images made by animals or machines.
“I so hope that wild animals are granted more and more fundamental rights in the future — like rights to dignity, survival, homeland, and their evolutionary privileges,” Slater wrote in a statement posted on his Facebook page. “They accept us as part of their landscape, with a big SMILE. We need to accept them as part of ours don’t you think?”
MTV’s The Exhibit Is Back With an Inflatable Dolphin
Episode four, in which artists tackled themes of justice and injustice, was the most lifeless of the reality TV show so far.
Florida Principal Ousted Over “Pornographic” Michelangelo Sculpture
Parents complained that the famous sculpture was shown to their sixth graders.
The Milton Resnick and Pat Passlof Foundation Presents The Feminine in Abstract Painting
Curated by Jennifer Samet and Andrea Belag, this group exhibition in NYC explores the feminine through aesthetics, as opposed to identity or gender.
Tickets to Sold-Out Vermeer Show Are Going for Hundreds
The online resale market for the Rijksmuseum’s smash exhibition is booming, with tickets selling on eBay for over $2K.
NYU Steinhardt Opens 2023 MFA Thesis Exhibitions
Taking place at 80WSE Gallery in New York’s Greenwich Village, Part I is on view from late March through April while Part II opens in May.
Miniature Worlds: Joseph Cornell, Ray Johnson, Yayoi Kusama
Through small-scale works, this exhibition at the Katonah Museum of Art in New York examines Cornell’s prominent role in the lives and careers of Johnson and Kusama.
Three Looted Antiquities at the Met Repatriated to Turkey
Nine other repatriated works were seized from Met Trustee Shelby White, whose collection was subject to a criminal investigation.
This week, the world’s lightest paint, Pakistan’s feminist movement, World Puppy Day, and were some of Vermeer’s paintings created by his daughter?
The Wider World and Scrimshaw
On March 28, join the New Bedford Whaling Museum online and in-person for a symposium on global carving traditions from across the Pacific Rim.
Who Will Decide on the Future of a Miami Native Burial Ground?
Native activists say sacred remains and objects dug up from a Brickell construction site should remain there, but mega-developer Jorge Pérez is pushing back.
How Can a Curator Approach South Asian Futurisms?
How do I acknowledge my shortcomings while reckoning with obscured histories and the exclusion of subaltern narratives in the fine art landscape? A working checklist for curators.
MCA Chicago Presents On Stage: Frictions
Will Rawls, Shamel Pitts | TRIBE, and Barak adé Soleil explore Blackness, queerness, movement, and dance in performances at the Museum of Contemporary Art Chicago.
The Complicated Legacy of Camilo Egas
The Ecuadorian painter, a leading figure of Latin America’s Indigenismo art movement, has been both praised and scorned for his representation of Indigenous peoples.
Tom Jones Zeroes in on Ho-Chunk Visibility
“I think about the young kids, the teenagers, and I think being able to see yourself represented in art is so powerful,” says the artist.