Appropriation is increasingly becoming a legal matter rather than an artistic one, in large part because Jeff Koons keeps finding himself as the subject of plagiarism lawsuits.
On Thursday, a Parisian court ordered Koons, alongside his personal company, the Pompidou Centre, and a book publisher, to jointly pay nearly $170,000 for breach of copyright and damages. The money will go to Franck Davidovici, the creator of a 1985 advertisement for the clothing company Naf Naf. The ad shares its name — and a multitude of similarities — with Koon’s 1988 statue, “Fait d’hiver.” The aggrieved party had originally asked for around $352,000 in damages.
Although the sculpture has been kicking around for the last 30 years, Davidovici only noticed the piece’s striking resemblance to his own work in a catalogue for the Centre Pompidou’s 2014 Koons retrospective. He sued for copyright infringement in January 2015 and even tried to have the work seized. Four years later, he won his case before France’s legal system.
Ironically, Koons was conspicuously absent from the opening of his Pompidou retrospective four years ago because he was battling yet another accusation of copyright infringement. This one came from the widow of photographer Jean-François Bauret whose work prompted the American fabricato’s sculpture “Naked” (1988). In 2017, he was found guilty of that plagiarism charge and was ordered to pay nearly $42,000 in damages alongside the Pompidou.
Fait d’hiver : l’œuvre de Jeff #Koons est jugée contrefaisante de la publicité #NafNaf. Le Tribunal écarte l’argument de la liberté d’expression artistique considérant que Koons avait manifestement cherché à faire « l’économie d’un travail créatif ». TGI Paris 081118 pic.twitter.com/t5vvSbkH1c
— Ox avocats (@Oxavocats) November 8, 2018
The recent court judgement against Koons rejected his freedom of artistic expression defense, which stated that the work should count as a parody. The artist implemented a variety of differences from Davidocivi’s original ad. His “Fait d’hiver” has a woman with sunglasses on her forehead and features two penguins. In Koons’ sculpture, the woman wears a see-through fishnet shirt while in the ad, she is more sensibly dressed for winter in a jacket and furs. The artist’s pig also wears a wreath of flowers whereas the admen’s pig has none.
But the court ruling also notes the “very recognizable staging” that ties the two objects together. The presence and positioning of the pig and woman together are an obvious parallel, but Koons also replicates exact details, like a strand of hair that falls onto the woman’s left cheek.
From his Banality series alone, Koons has incurred a total of five copyright infringement lawsuits. “Fait d’hiver” is just the latest work in the series to face backlash. Still, one edition of the sculpture sold for $4.3 million at Christie’s in 2007. It is now in the collection of the Prada Foundation.
On that note, some have observed that Koons’ $170,000 fine is a paltry sum compared to the multimillion-dollar estimated value of the sculpture.
Sam P. Israel is a New York attorney specializing in intellectual property law. He tells Hyperallergic that Koons would have incurred far steeper fines if the case was litigated in the United States. “Jeff Koons, who does make art derivative of existing cultural images as a practice, should recognize his responsibility to those who create images for profit,” he said. “If the matter was pursued on US soil, the price tag for the infringement would have been considerably higher and reflect the huge sums Mr. Koons has and will continue to reap from the work.”
Davidovici’s lawyer, Jeff Koons’s studio, and the Pompidou Centre have not yet released official statements on the ruling yet.
Bobby Wilson Combats Indigenous Stereotypes Through Humor
The artist-performer’s career undulates, ever so gracefully, across multiple mediums and registers of generational pain, healing laughter, and Indigenous joy.
Rare 19th-Century Silhouette Album’s Secrets Unlocked
Traveling portrait artist William Bache’s album depicts famous figures like Thomas Jefferson as well as people whose identity was previously unknown.
Nevada Museum of Art Presents Adaline Kent: The Click of Authenticity
For the first time in nearly 60 years, the innovative yet under-recognized artist is the subject of a retrospective exhibition. On view in Reno, Nevada.
Artists Show What They Can Do With a Google Phone’s Camera
Works by 21 photographers are now on view in Manhattan for the seventh season and 100th project coming out of the Google Creator Labs.
Met Museum Kicked Me Out for Praying to My Ancestral Gods
My danced prayer to looted Cambodian antiquities was too much for the New York museum.
The Public Theater in NYC Presents Plays for the Plague Year
Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Suzan-Lori Parks’s theatrical concert chronicles the 2020 lockdown and the hope and perseverance that emerged from it.
A Museum Guard’s Ode to the Healing Power of Art
In All the Beauty in the World, Patrick Bringley revisits the many ways that art meets life, and life art, and how death is often the bridge between them.
UK Extends Export Ban on Coveted “Portrait of Omai”
London’s National Portrait Gallery was given a few months to acquire the work, which depicts the first Polynesian visitor to the UK.
Mondays at Pratt Institute: Weekly Openings of Work by Graduating Artists
Free and open to the public, Pratt Shows celebrate the school’s graduating students. MFA and BFA work on view this spring in Brooklyn, New York.
The Sculptor Making Art With Loved Ones’ Ashes
Inspired by the three-year anniversary of the COVID-19 pandemic, Julian Stair’s exhibition honors the lives of eight people with cinerary jars.
Art Institute of Chicago Under Scrutiny Over Sacred Nepali Necklace
The 17th-century object remains on display at the Chicago museum despite Nepal’s calls for repatriation.
LSU School of Art Grants Highest MFA Stipends in the Southern US
With funded assistantships, full tuition waivers, and generous stipends, Louisiana State University helps students lay the groundwork for a successful lifelong art practice.
Art Problems: How Do I Get a Public Art Commission?
Want to leave a mark on your city or town, but don’t know where to start? Paddy Johnson has some tips.
Rose B. Simpson Embeds Ancestral Histories in Clay
She has taken clay and used it to recall its ancestral roots in Pueblo culture and address the present history of postcolonial recovery and ongoing trauma.
lawyers could realize more profit if dogs and cats and trees and rocks could sue artists (and other advertisers) for defamation. (sic 4 all of it ! )
Why do you keep referring to this persistent phony and plagiarist as an artist?
Why are the sums asked in the lawsuit so small? If I was Davidovici I would immediately make a sculpture based on my 1985 ad and sell it for 2 million vs the 6 million Koons wants for his…
Seems Koons has lost his ability to create…anything but invoices for those who can afford his over-priced “Look-at-me” products
Comments are closed.