Ciara O’Connor had recently returned to London after vacationing in New York when she decided to visit the Tate Modern’s latest exhibition, Olafur Eliasson: In Real Life. But upon entering the galleries, the wheelchair user quickly realized that many of the interactive installations were inaccessible and out of reach for people like her with disabilities.
On Friday, O’Connor, who writes for the Irish Sunday Independent newspaper, detailed on Twitter her frustration when trying to enter Eliasson’s “Spiral View” (2002), a 26-foot-long tunnel constructed from reflective steel plates that produce a kaleidoscopic effect inside.
It’s been 23 hours since I posted an Instagram story about my trip to @Tate
. A load of people shared it there, tagging the protagonists, asking for answers. Have heard nowt, and it’s about expire. So I’m going to have to dust off my Twitter to #askSOE – and I ask you to, too.
— Ciara (@Cioconnor) August 9, 2019
“I’ve just come out of Tate Modern, to see Olafur Eliasson’s exhibition, In Real Life. It’s a series of mostly interactive installations that play with light, mirrors, mist, fire, water. A couple of pieces were too high for me to play with, but whatever — that’s unavoidable,” she posted.
“At the end, there’s a whole room dedicated to a mirrored tunnel: you’re meant to walk through it. It had two steps up to it. In the grand scheme of supremely inaccessible London, it barely registered.”
At the end, there’s a whole room dedicated to a mirrored tunnel: you’re meant to walk through it. It had two steps up to it. In the grand scheme of supremely inaccessible London, it barely registered. pic.twitter.com/nIJWzIjPAV
— Ciara (@Cioconnor) August 9, 2019
O’Connor’s friend Alice asked an attendant if there was a ramp available, but he became “cross and weirdly defensive,” according to the writer. The attendant reportedly told Alice that not having a ramp was “the curator’s choice” and suggested that O’Connor simply “go around the side.”
Eliasson responded to O’Connor’s Twitter thread, saying that the sculpture is “old” and that “to acknowledge its original shape while offering full access, I am exploring solutions with Tate.” The Danish-Icelandic artist promised that he would let her know “when we have news.” The Tate also responded to O’Connor’s post, saying it was working with Eliasson and his studio to address the situation.
Dear Ciara. Thanks for shouting out loud. I really appreciate that. I did Your spiral view in 2002 so it’s an old sculpture. To acknowledge its original shape while offering full access, I am exploring solutions with Tate. Will definitely let you know when we have news. Olafur https://t.co/rGenOAiNsC
— StudioOlafurEliasson (@olafureliasson) August 11, 2019
In a statement today, the Tate apologized for its lack of wheelchair access, but after “a full assessment” with Eliasson and technicians, decided that the sculpture “cannot be made safely accessible for wheelchair users.” The museum said that “even if a ramp were added, the mirrored walkway that is an integral part of the sculpture is structurally too narrow to be made safe for wheelchair use.”
“We decided to include ‘Your Spiral View’ in the exhibition as it is the only sculpture of its type in Olafur Eliasson’s body of work which can be loaned for exhibitions, and a more accessible alternative does not exist. We recognize that this has caused an access issue for wheelchair users for which we are sorry and the comments we have received will be taken on board in future decision-making.”
O’Connor had anticipated these comments in her Twitter thread, noting that Eliasson himself explores questions of interactivity, bodies, responsibility, and agency throughout the exhibition. Numerous texts for the show talk about changing the experience of seeing art. She pointed out one particular line that reads: “In a museum, we all move as if we don’t have a body — or at least we don’t refer to bodily movement as a co-producing element when we’re looking at art.”
She responded to the sentiment in another post: “Fuck that. Fuck your over-intellectualizing and big talk that obscures the fact that you only produce, curate, exhibit art for certain bodies. Fuck you for assuming that everyone who likes art and museums gets to ‘move as if they don’t have a body.’”
“I never get to lose myself in a picture, or wander in a reverie,” she added, “I am always, ALWAYS aware of my body, how it’s blocking people, how it’s taking up space, how it’s inconvenient and cumbersome.”
“That’s the story of my life, and of every disabled person’s life. Going around things. Looking from the outside. Watching other people enjoy life, art, transport, whatever, the way that it’s ‘supposed’ to be enjoyed … I want a fucking ramp. I want elevators. I want wide doorways. I want accessible toilets that aren’t storage cupboards. I want to get on a train, and go to a place all by myself. I don’t want to ask permission. I don’t want to be grateful for every reasonable adjustment.”
I paid money today for an art exhibition which talked the talk about interactivity, bodies, responsibility, agency. pic.twitter.com/qN5pMLy0l3
— Ciara (@Cioconnor) August 9, 2019
O’Connor’s response has struck a chord with social media users; her Twitter thread has gained over 2,200 retweets and more than 3,700 likes. Ableism in the art world has become a global issue with conversations developing about everything from the presence of benches in galleries to how cultural institutions have failed to accommodate disabled and neurodiverse communities within their walls. In January, more than 75 galleries were sued under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) for failing to make their websites accessible to the blind and visually impaired. And in April, protesters picketed architect Thomas Heatherwick’s “Vessel” at Hudson Yards. Activists from the Anti-Stairs Club organized a demonstration of disabled and non-disabled individuals who saw the honeycomb structure of 154 stairways as flouting the rules of ADA compliance.
Responding to O’Connor’s experience, Twitter users with disabilities shared stories of their own difficult experiences with museums. Deborah Persaud said she was unable to access “Your Spiral View” with her guide dog because there was no safety mat for the grid floor, which would have hurt her dog’s paws. “No alternative offered but attendant [very] apologetic. Could have worked if someone held him and I was guided,” Persaud added
Some commenters had also questioned whether or not the Tate’s Access Advisory Group still exists. Several users said they had once participated with the group, but have not been asked back. The Tate did not immediately respond for comment on whether or not the advisory body still exists.
Remembering the Migrants Who Died in US Detention
Artist Jackie Amézquita will lead a caravan of trucks with the names of the deceased to LA sites representing systems of oppression and solidarity for immigrants.
Mark Thomas Gibson’s Cartoons See the US Going Nowhere
If Thomas Nast, who is considered the “Father of the American Cartoon,” has an heir, it is Gibson, who goes one step further and elevates caricature and commentary into art.
LSU School of Art Grants Highest MFA Stipends in the Southern US
With funded assistantships, full tuition waivers, and generous stipends, Louisiana State University helps students lay the groundwork for a successful lifelong art practice.
Kahori Kamiya Transmutes Grief Into Play
Through artworks that encourage viewers to explore varied vantages, Kamiya conveys her accrued wisdom and experiences without the weight of their pain.
Maya Deren in Vivid Focus
Maya Deren: Choreographed for Camera depicts how the artist’s life and ideas cemented her place as a champion and influencer of culture.
School of the Art Institute of Chicago Offers Summer Art and Design Courses Online and On-Campus
Emerging and established artists can choose from over 50 Adult Continuing Education courses at one of the most influential art and design schools in the US.
AI Image Generators Finally Figured Out Hands
Midjourney fixed its inability to render hands realistically, one of the telltale signs of an image being AI-generated.
Lorraine O’Grady, Emily Jacir Among American Academy of Arts’s 2023 Awardees
Artist Faith Ringgold and scholar Helen Hennessy Vendler received this year’s gold medals.
IDSVA Offers a Non-Studio PhD in Visual Arts: Philosophy, Aesthetics, and Art Theory
With no campus, the Institute for Doctoral Studies in the Visual Arts is a truly nomadic institution, existing everywhere our students and faculty are.
MTV’s The Exhibit Needs a Cutthroat Judge
In episode three, the artists created works about the pandemic and bonded with each other, which is cute but doesn’t really make for good TV.
Cauleen Smith’s Drylongso Depicts a Bygone Oakland
Smith’s 1998 film exudes the DIY charm of a low-budget, first-time feature while keenly depicting the complexities of both race- and gender-related inequalities.
Tyler School of Art and Architecture Opens 2023 MFA Thesis Exhibition Series
Students working in diverse disciplines explore temporality, connectedness in time and space, and global reckonings. On view in Philadelphia.
Take Ai Weiwei’s Middle Finger Anywhere in the World
A new collaboration between the artist and Avant Arte invites users to flip the bird anywhere and everywhere on Google Maps.
This week, gifted DeSantis a “fascist” snowflake, NASA’s Webb telescope captures a supernova, corporatizing London’s creativity, and much more.
I get this issue. It is urgent and important, but at what point is the whole artworld just going to cancel itself?
Right. Reasonable accommodations for disabled people in public spaces should be made wherever possible, but at some point it feels as though disabled people lose sight (no pun intended) of the fact that their condition is called a disability for a reason. Throwing tantrums over reminders that you won’t get to do certain things or go to the same places as able-bodied people smacks of living in denial and a lack of self-acceptance of one’s condition they’re attempting to redirect as ableism.
It isn’t an artist’s job to ensure their art is made accessible to everyone. A lot of visual art can’t be enjoyed by blind people. A lot of structural art can’t be enjoyed by mobility-challenged individuals. A lot of art that relies primarily on sound can’t be enjoyed by hearing-impaired people. And so on and on. If it’s required of artists that their work takes every possible handicap and impairment of their potential audience into consideration, then art as we know it will cease to exist. Getting to enjoy an art installation is a privilege and not a right. It shouldn’t be subject to the regulations and standards that public businesses providing essential services and products are.
It would be much more reasonable to lobby for disabled artists to be recognized in the art world and have their works showcased at museums, that way everybody wins and no one is inconvenienced. This is what other minority groups who feel underrepresented in art have done, rather than whine that other artists have some kind of duty to include their existence in their art work.
Seems like a simple ramp to the side might fix the tunnel issue? On the other hand, do people stop creating entirely if the work can’t be accessible to every possible impairment? My own personal impairment is that I ain’t rich.
Comments are closed.