Museums in the United Kingdom may be able to return objects on the basis of a “moral obligation,” according to new legislation to be implemented this fall. Experts say that the Charities Act 2022, which was passed by the UK Parliament earlier this year, may have consequences for restitution cases.
Alexander Herman, director of the UK Institute of Art and Law, detailed the significance of the Charities Act in a preview of a forthcoming article to be published in the institute’s quarterly journal. Currently, museums in the UK, most of which are charities, must govern their collections by statute, meaning that trustees are limited in what they can remove from them and return by legal precedent. Most notably, in 2005, the High Court of Justice in London ruled that the British Museum Act 1963 prevented museums from disposing of items in their collection except under very rare circumstances. The British Museum’s official policy on deaccessions, for instance, specifies that the British Museum Act of 1963 disempowers the museum’s trustees from removing or returning objects unless they are “unfit to be retained in the Collection” and “can be disposed of without detriment to the interests of the public or scholars” — a standard that the museum has cited in explaining why it cannot restitute certain times.
New provisions in the Charities Act 2022 suggest that national museums may make ex gratia transfers — or transfers that are undertaken for reasons of morality. Under these provisions, trustees can independently decide to dispose of property deemed as “low valued” (with this value dependent on the museum’s size). For items of higher value, trustees can petition the Charity Commission for authorization to return objects when there is a strong “moral claim.” The Charities Act also provides new guidance on how to arbitrate whether a moral obligation to return an item exists, setting that standard as a “reasonably held belief” that a moral claim exists.
“The 2022 Act will not lead to the restitution of vast amounts of museum material, since the ex gratia power can be used only in rare cases,” Herman wrote. “But the additional tools will nevertheless prove useful to trustees who, until now, may have felt handcuffed by the legal restrictions of their governing statutes.”
The Charity Commission has recently approved two high-profile restitution cases — one involving the return of 72 Benin bronzes from London’s Horniman Museum to Nigeria and the other initiating the return of a Benin bronze from Cambridge’s Jesus College to Nigeria.
Spokespeople at both the Victoria and Albert Museum and the British Museum reiterated in an email to Hyperallergic that they are exempt museums established by statute, each adding that they would be following the progress of the new Charities Act “with interest.”
All the Beauty and the Bloodshed forcefully posits multiple parallels between the world Nan Goldin grew up in and the one she fights in today.
Your list of must-see, fun, insightful, and very Los Angeles art events this month, including Bob Thompson, Aimee Goguen, Uta Barth, the Transcendental Painting Group, and more.
The latest episode of this documentary series on PBS explores the meaning of home through handmade objects, hand built homes, and the artists who create them.
There is the singular artist and then there is the more exclusive club that has only one member. Harvey belongs to the latter.
The artists say the Museum of Contemporary Art Kiasma must sever ties with Poju Zabludowicz, whose wealth comes in part from Israeli defense contracting.
Rhode Island School of Design opens registration for its residential summer Pre-College program and year-round online intensive Advanced Program Online.
Vanessa Albury, whose eco-friendly ceramic sculptures help revive filter-feeder populations, is raising funds to complete her first film about the project.
An archeological exploration of the amphitheater’s sewers and water systems uncovered remnants of meat, vegetables, olives, nuts, and yes, pizza.
Hrag Vartanian, Hyperallergic’s editor-in-chief, is one of the guest jurors reviewing applications for the two-month residency in Utica, New York.
At this year’s show, I reflected on the lack of bilingual materials, the absurdity of art-fair gimmick, and the workers who make it all possible.
Your list of must-see, fun, insightful, and very New York art events this month, including art made during the first stock market crash, a homage to feline friends, and the 10-year anniversary of a crucial public art initiative.
Hear a band of improvisers led by Rajna Swaminathan and a performance of Morton Feldman’s “For John Cage” in programs inspired by the exhibition, “New York: 1962-1964.”
Astrid Dick was told that she could not paint stripes because Sean Scully and Frank Stella have done so before her, a patently foolish statement.
Paddy Johnson answers your questions about art fairs, visibility, and frustrating studio visits.